kwanb wrote:Points well taken - I am happy to have a well informed discussion and I apologize for making assumptions about your the amount you train without knowing you well.
With regards to the point about punching is that its not a good example. No one trains breathing in when punching so that it becomes a habit. I am arguing uddhiyana bandha becomes a habit. In a stressful situation you may suck in your stomach with a deep intake of breath, losing your root, without thinking.
Just like an amateur stand up comedian who is well known for his sexist jokes may let one slip during an important job interview with a pretty woman. Probably couldn't control it.
ok, a better example would probably be tensing your abs when someone hits you in the stomach: few people accidentally tense their abs when they don't need it.
doing uddhiyana bandha has a reason, and this reason has nothing to do with exerting strength outwards, so i doubt many people would do it accidentally in a fight.
one of the problems i see often is the persoanlity type you talked about: the idea that you have to go full power and exert yourself, or you won't progress.
that's totally wrong though. keep in mind that old taoist saying "my way is simple and natural."
the reason for this is that the body is like a machine. you can fine tune it, but you shouldn't go at it with a sledgehammer. gaining certain skills and abilities takes time, and going at it full throttle will just destroy your "machine".
medically speaking, a light stimulus will strengthen, a strong stimulus will damage. you ideally want to build up energy, not deplete it.
here's an example: suppose you want calloused feet. you'd naturally run on coarse ground. this is a light stimulus.
the "hard tough way" would be taking a cheese grater to your feet 2 times a week.
meh, i'm rambling, but you get the idea.