jbb73 wrote:the meaning of juezhao (絶招)?
jbb73 wrote:Hy there,
can somebody help me with the meaning of juezhao (絶招)?
I think it is something like "techniques", but assume there is a more specialized meaning or context in which the term is used...
Thanks!
jbb73 wrote:Hy there,
can somebody help me with the meaning of juezhao (絶招)?
I think it is something like "techniques", but assume there is a more specialized meaning or context in which the term is used...
Thanks!
edededed wrote:Hey Wuyizidi, good to see you back
Great description of juezhao! In my experience, though, baguazhang does have a set of juezhao (72 juezhao) - perhaps reflecting its somewhat eclectic nature (it likes to do everything). Of course as you say, no technique is 100% foolproof, but one way to keep effectiveness is to keep their knowledge secret (because if everyone knows, it probably won't work so well).
But to be honest, some sets of "powers" (like xingyi's "dantian strike" skill) are more "absolute" than the juezhao (which are more like well-thought techniques - maybe due to the word "zhao").
My experience with taijiquan is much less, but I wonder if there are any similar sorts of things in taiji, too.
Wuyizidi wrote:jbb73 wrote:
External martial art relies on pre-designed skill: I do this, and you, being a reasonable person, would likely to counter with that, and I, having researched this deeply before, found a really clever way to get you based on your reaction... This way in a fight, they can execute a technique exactly as they have done hundreds of thousands of times before in practice. That's the idea in external martial art. They do something you have not seen before very quickly and perfectly, and that secures the victory.
jbb73 wrote:I have to disagree. In my opinion, and based on more than 25 years intensive training in different "external" martial arts: this seems a really naive view to me. You don´t really think in a fight - be it judo, boxing or knock-down-karate - you operate on that kind of plan??? Sorry, that´s ridiculous.
Wuyizidi wrote:This by the way is a major difference between internal martial art and external martial art. In external martial art, people really try to keep their techniques secret (the "unexpected" part of formula).
External martial art relies on pre-designed skill: I do this, and you, being a reasonable person, would likely to counter with that, and I, having researched this deeply before, found a really clever way to get you based on your reaction... This way in a fight, they can execute a technique exactly as they have done hundreds of thousands of times before in practice. That's the idea in external martial art. They do something you have not seen before very quickly and perfectly, and that secures the victory.
In internal martial art people don't talk about secret jue zhao. Internal martial art focus on developing general abilities about dealing with force. So in Taiji we say "it doesn't matter what you do, I'm not going to do what you expect me to do, I'll let your initial contact move me, but in a way that now it's awkward for you to really exert a force on me at that point". In Bagua it's like "ok you expect me to block you here, fine I'll touch you, but from that touch I'll control you and change the centerline on you, so now you can't hit me but I can hit you", in Xingyi people will do "ok you want me to block your hand here, but from that touch I'll exert a crossing force..." In all three cases, sensitive and control (using internal force) creates problem for the jue zhao so that it cannot proceed as designed.
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan