I can fight, and try to apply tai chi to fighting. Just perhaps not very well. I'm working on that. That's what the sparring sets are for.
Every body can fight. Why would one have to apply something to "fighting" that they already practice.
This means one is outside their practice. Boxers don't' apply what they train, they "do" they are...There is no separation between what they practice and what they do.
Push hands IMO once turned into a competitive event has / is / one of the worst development tracks in taiji.
It destroyed how the art was, could be, used. One can theorize all they want about swimming, wont prevent them from drowning.
For many taiji people they want to feel another's push hands while this has some indication of skill and is in its self a kind of skill, the question is for what and what kind of skill.
In China, I knocked a guy down once who looked like he had learned from my teacher. I saw him practicing and mentioned it looked like we had the same teacher In my broken Chinese, he could speak no English. He said lets push....and proceeded to try to do as many do "fight" or "win" which caused him to be knocked down...He then said "this was not the taiji of our teacher" I said ok...
He got back up this time he stopped trying to fight or win, which allowed for both of us to explore and feel differences in skill and understanding.
He then smiled and remarked "yes, this is correct"
I don't teach push hands, I do teach those I work with the principles whereby it works, and use it as an "exercise" among others in my own work and training.
In a recent trip to Peace Park in Taipei, the people there thought my skills set was pretty good, although I would be the first not to say so.
They practice and do push hands.
http://taichitaiwan.blogspot.tw/2008/12 ... ping2.html If you or anyone want to test their push hands skill with people who do push hands this might be a good place to go. For me its not something I do...nor view in the same light...