Re: A Note on Some history: Wang's pupil beat SunLuTang?
Posted: Fri Sep 11, 2009 11:59 am
Tom wrote:Both Sun and Wang are dead now. Let them rest in peace. Less storytelling, more training.
+1
D.
Sarcasm. Oh yeah, like that´ll work.
dedicated to the discussion of the chinese internal martial arts of xingyiquan, baguazhang, taijiquan, related arts, and anything else best discussed over a bottle of rum
http://rumsoakedfist.org/
Tom wrote:Both Sun and Wang are dead now. Let them rest in peace. Less storytelling, more training.
Bao wrote:eastpaw wrote:Bao wrote:But I can say that 1928 was very late in Suns life. He lived 1860-1933. This was five years before his death. There lies no honor in defeating an old man. But I don't believe that he would fight. He had stopped fighting a long time ago.
A 68-year old IMA master would actually be one helluva scary dude.
Well yeah, I know older and scary dudes. But this is China 1928
1. Sun Lutang had stopped practice for fighting.
2. In 1920s China 68 was a very old age.
3. At that time, young people was taught to gave the most respect for older people. To challenge someone that old would mean a loss of face.
C.J.Wang wrote:Let's look at this using another story as an example: Wang Xiang-Zhai's students claim that Wang had beaten Xingyi master Shang Yun-Shiang, but from Shang's camp, people contend that it was Shang who beat Wang. So who's telling the truth?
Take these stories with a grain of salt might be the best thing to do.