Shanghaijay wrote:cdobe wrote:I've met Shen Tiegen just last Sunday in Frankfurt/Germany, where he is currently living. Shen is a very nice person. We've practiced tuishou, dalü and free wrestling together for about three hours. He is very open to play, but not very open to discuss the basic training. Only after I've indicated Wu style indoor exercises myself, were we able to compare and discuss them a little. He demonstrated some interesting forms he had learned, like the san huang pao chui, lan cai hua or the double sword form that he learned fro Wu Yinghua. He also showed chicken stepping from Xinyi.
I would say, that if you visit him once in order to learn some exercises to incorporate into your own practice, you will be very disappointed, because he is not going to show you any. You will have to stay with him and train with him for some time in order to be trained properly.
Not to be the devils advocate but if you don't speak Chinese, discussions are going to be at best on a very rudimentary level. Moreover, the best way to really understand Shen and what he is trying to teach is to touch him. Words are so far away from the experience it is ridiculous to assume that you can really learn anything from him by talking. You have to stay with anyone a while in order to be trained properly. This is just common sense.
Jay
Jay,
first of all, I'm not looking for a teacher. I went to see Shen out of curiosity, because of all the positive things you and others had to say about him. I am already very capable of performing the forms, shou fa and supplementary exercises as transmitted by Ma Yueliang. Nothing he did, except for the double sword form, was new to me.
Second, as I have clearly written, I've
practiced with him. I've mostly asked him with my hands, in a respectful way of course. BTW, he's in my region at the moment and was in my town just yesterday. I haven't seen him once.
Third, I have never lived in China, but I did study Chinese in the past. I'm not good at it, but we made ourselves understood without any bigger problems.
Lastly, you should drop your elitism. I remember your words:
some of us - meaning yourself -
have seen and felt more than others. Guess what? You haven't. I'm not sure about the other way around.
You're not helping your honourable teacher by acting that way.
@Kreese
Shen stresses this very often. At about 114.4 lbs he says, that anything else wouldn't work for him. So he emphasises the qualities of softness and change. He also often talks about not having any techniques at your mind, while doing free work. His Tuishou is very non competitive in nature. Unlike other teachers of this branch, the fixed Tuishou routines are not very challenging and comparatively slow. He says Tuishou is not for pushing each other. It's all about cooperatively training listening with different parts of your body. When the other person pressures, there is a change and an application.
As for the offbalancing at the first touch, with this soft approach, it all depends on the commitment and the root of the puncher, of course.