GrahamB wrote:Byron,
Feng, FaKe's daughter, and the others on the bench are direct students of Chen FaKe,
She does not appear to have been a student of Chen Fake.
bartekb wrote:wow so complicated, all the lineage, hstory and ancestory...if only there was a way to see whose taichi is better...oh wait...
Byron,
Feng, FaKe's daughter, and the others on the bench are direct students of Chen FaKe, making them 18th generation Chen-style, while the back row of CXW and the others ... those guys are 19th generation. So naturally they go to the back row. It's traditional to have the earlier generation in the front and it means nothing about ability, etc.
My point was that whoever you are a student of seems to colour your version of history, and that we can't know either way what happened.
willie wrote:This is how my teacher moves Charles. "Note that forward lean". Zhang Lu Ping was from Chen Zhaokui.
so about half is from Chen Zhaokui's side, the other half from Wang Hai Jun / Chen Zhenglei side.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGWJxJndw6o
GrahamB wrote:I am neither a student of anyone in this debate or Chen style either. My point was that whoever you are a student of seems to colour your version of history, and that we can't know either way what happened.
willie wrote:This is how my teacher moves Charles.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 43 guests