Pavel Macek wrote:According my experience, training forms and hoping that the footwork (or anything) will come alive when needed doesn't work in approximately 10 cases out of 10. Approximately. Although forms are very useful, it is a must to go beyond forms, and practice so called Saan Sau Bin Fa (Applications and their Variations), leading to Saan Da, Free Fighting. Sparring with fighters from various combat arts, such as boxing, Muay Thai, or in the best case MMA, helps a lot. My 2 RMB.
Pavel, I didn't say that form alone was necessary. I said the foundations are developed through correct instruction of the basics, one method of which is forms. As I pointed out, my experience is that I have rarely seen that detail in the Hung Gar I see out there. Most want to be low wide and fast in their shiny uniforms. Looks impressive to the untrained eye but lacks depth.
As for sparring with other schools, it has its place. Much depends on your purpose. Certainly if you plan to compete it should play a role.