Bao wrote:Why not just trap and punch? Then you don’t need to throw.
Trick wrote:Bao wrote:Why not just trap and punch? Then you don’t need to throw.
Too easy
johnwang wrote:This way, not only you can still train your push, you have also learned 2 new leg skills. Your thought?
windwalker wrote:johnwang wrote:This way, not only you can still train your push, you have also learned 2 new leg skills. Your thought?
Don't train to push, why would anyone train for that.
Train to hit, shock,break, or throw, each depending on contact time and or point of contact.
Leg skills are punching skills.
willie wrote:windwalker wrote:johnwang wrote:This way, not only you can still train your push, you have also learned 2 new leg skills. Your thought?
Don't train to push, why would anyone train for that.
Train to hit, shock,break, or throw, each depending on contact time and or point of contact.
Leg skills are punching skills.
Cool! Are we going to be able to see you do a video of this type of stuff?
Steve James wrote:John, the way I was taught, "An" (what is translated as "push") really means something more like "push down" or 'the action of' pushing down. Anyway, why do you think "push hands" is called "tuishou" and not "anshou?" In Chinese, do people "tui" a car or "an" a car? I agree with your idea of throwing, but but isn't it more about pushing up?
In general, though, I think that throwing is fine for people young and fit enough to participate in sport. I think people would be interested in which specific movements from the form that you would use or compare to shuaijiao techniques.
windwalker wrote:
Don't train to push, why would anyone train for that.
Train to hit, shock,break, or throw, each depending on contact time and or point of contact.
I've broken others arms in my time...borken means clean breaks on the Ulna accidently
through the contact point.
If you think training to push someone is good cool...
can you post a clip of fajin in use ?
willie wrote:Of course I can offer a video of fajin in use, I have already showed many many videos, where is yours?
windwalker wrote:willie wrote:Of course I can offer a video of fajin in use, I have already showed many many videos, where is yours?
lets be clear and honest.
You have shown demos nothing more.
The demos posted seem to accord with your experience
for others they may not....
JW talks about pushing maybe confusing what long and short force is, and why its trained. For most taiji people they use whats called long force in demos
to show and allow others to feel something with out damaging them. Often they get stuck in demo mode and never use or understand how to use whats called
"cold jin" or short power....
willie wrote:How about a video? J W has provided videos from time to time.
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 88 guests