wayne hansen wrote:Not only can I reproduce what he does I can teach an untrained guy to do it in 5 minutes
Best post so far in this thread.
wayne hansen wrote:Not only can I reproduce what he does I can teach an untrained guy to do it in 5 minutes
Bao wrote:No I don’t agree with Mizner’s explanation or anything he says here. And I don’t believe that his explanation is very common.
Here is something similar but explained very different. Who do you believe is the most advanced player Mizner or Lü?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eU0nI1VPaNk
if you try to follow what he says, and he needs a compliant partner who nearly falls on him.
They're both demos, no ? Are not all demos compliant in nature?
Lü can do what he does unrehearsed on any student and anyone can follow, learn and replicate what he does with enough practice.
Because what he does based primarily on structure should be easy to follow and replicate. He speaks of "opening and closing"
but uses terminology that he is comfortable with according to his understanding.
Why should anyone even care about who could do what Mizner does or say when they can follow a person as Lü step by step and learn to do the same?
Of course they'er not the same. Yes they are different.
One using structure to control, the other Minzner, not..at least not to the same degree.
Advanced in what way ?
better "demo" or what ?
Bao wrote:
I wrote: "Who do you believe is the most advanced player Mizner or Lü?"
It should be obvious that I didn't ask about any demo. I asked about which one one them, Mizner or Lu, that has most advanced skill and knowledge. Who is the better Tai Chi practitioner in terms of skill and knowledge? ...Anyone is allowed to reply.
wayne hansen wrote:Not only can I reproduce what he does I can teach an untrained guy to do it in 5 minutes
windwalker wrote:Of course one could always compare their market,
who has more students or views.
Would that not be a fair indication.
wayne hansen wrote:Then I explain why you don’t train in that manner
Due to the fact it limits your advancement in the art
Quigga wrote:Doc, I admit to having emotions that may not be perfectly regulated No offence taken.
My skill probably isn't enough to discern who's better.
wayne hansen wrote:Because we are training to go beyond thought into instinctive action it is not possible to train one way and demo another.
wayne hansen wrote:What you say would apply to any martial art
However you can see things that will work in a negative manner to retard development
Return to Been There Done That
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 75 guests