Hello Bao,
I am not sure your name is Chinese name or English, since we have the same sound "bao" in Chinese with good meaning.
I am curious also that is English your first language? Because i am confused: your writing is very good. But it seems that you like to make some new stuff by yourself. If you do not believe me, please read what you have written (there are a lot of same stuff but I only pick one as a sample):
"So back to my question: What I think is curious is that if the XingYi practice is very strict and focused, how can you at the same time teach another kind of shenfa for the same students? And if you can do that, why are you so strict with the XY shenfa?
If you can mix different body methods, it doesn't matter if you mix two different styles or does it in one style. Either you are very strict and teach one kind of shen fa and have your students to stick to that one. The other option is that you are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring."
"So back to my question: What I think is curious is that if the XingYi practice is very strict and focused, how can you at the same time teach another kind of shenfa for the same students?"
Answer: can you teach that? Maybe you can. Since you are asking this question so maybe you want to improve your skill of teaching. But i have to be direct to you that I cannot and I never did. I only teach students the second style after years of practicing the first style. Or, at least, that the person knows how to separate the different practices from different styles.
So have you heard anyone teach like you said which mix two together? Did i mention that in my article?
"And if you can do that, why are you so strict with the XY shenfa? "
Answer: I told you already that I can not. IF you can, could you PLEASE share some wisdom with us?
Shenfa? What is that? I do not know the meaning... or we have the different dictionary to the same words. Do you know what the Shenfa mean in Chinese? At least I can not guess the meaning from what you wrote...
This is a frequently used words in EF, still I do not know it.
"If you can mix different body methods, it doesn't matter if you mix two different styles or does it in one style. Either you are very strict and teach one kind of shen fa and have your students to stick to that one. The other option is that you are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring."
Answer: You make me more confused now, sorry for my poor English.
But maybe you are the ONLY martial art instructor who are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring. The reason? because it seems that you can mix up two styles together to your students. OR you do not know application, techniques or sparring at all, so you want to use Shenfa, the word you even do not know, to fool others. Sorry for my straightness, it is my personality that I can not tolerate your unreasonable hypothesis at all.
If you teach martial art as I do, I would like to say more to you: Do not get me wrong please Bao, I teach 3 styles and I mastered 3 styles. I do not want to be too humble to you now since you like to coach others a lot. And you like to make up some words and twisted it then ask people for Evil knows reason (not God knows reason here).
For your other writing on your posted message, there are many mistakes as well, I do not want to point them out here since it is not my business. Since you asked me some questions, i have to give a quick answer.
Please do not blame us that I asked my student to post this message for me.
By the way, your name in Chinese has many good meanings, such as Treasure, precious, protect and others...
Hai Yang
p.s.: May I ask a favor from you? I would like to take some of your question from your posts and give answers then show them to my students, to clarify some common misunderstanding or mistakes. Is it ok with you? If so, I will really appreciate it, because you know, sometimes, pointing out mistakes are more helpful to students than showing a good sample only.
I will wait for your answer.
xingyijuan wrote:Mr Yang asked me to post this as an answer:Hello Bao,
I am not sure your name is Chinese name or English, since we have the same sound "bao" in Chinese with good meaning.
I am curious also that is English your first language? Because i am confused: your writing is very good. But it seems that you like to make some new stuff by yourself. If you do not believe me, please read what you have written (there are a lot of same stuff but I only pick one as a sample):
"So back to my question: What I think is curious is that if the XingYi practice is very strict and focused, how can you at the same time teach another kind of shenfa for the same students? And if you can do that, why are you so strict with the XY shenfa?
If you can mix different body methods, it doesn't matter if you mix two different styles or does it in one style. Either you are very strict and teach one kind of shen fa and have your students to stick to that one. The other option is that you are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring."
"So back to my question: What I think is curious is that if the XingYi practice is very strict and focused, how can you at the same time teach another kind of shenfa for the same students?"
Answer: can you teach that? Maybe you can. Since you are asking this question so maybe you want to improve your skill of teaching. But i have to be direct to you that I cannot and I never did. I only teach students the second style after years of practicing the first style. Or, at least, that the person knows how to separate the different practices from different styles.
So have you heard anyone teach like you said which mix two together? Did i mention that in my article?
"And if you can do that, why are you so strict with the XY shenfa? "
Answer: I told you already that I can not. IF you can, could you PLEASE share some wisdom with us?
Shenfa? What is that? I do not know the meaning... or we have the different dictionary to the same words. Do you know what the Shenfa mean in Chinese? At least I can not guess the meaning from what you wrote...
This is a frequently used words in EF, still I do not know it.
"If you can mix different body methods, it doesn't matter if you mix two different styles or does it in one style. Either you are very strict and teach one kind of shen fa and have your students to stick to that one. The other option is that you are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring."
Answer: You make me more confused now, sorry for my poor English.
But maybe you are the ONLY martial art instructor who are not concerned about building shen fa and focus on applications, techniques and/or maybe sparring. The reason? because it seems that you can mix up two styles together to your students. OR you do not know application, techniques or sparring at all, so you want to use Shenfa, the word you even do not know, to fool others. Sorry for my straightness, it is my personality that I can not tolerate your unreasonable hypothesis at all.
If you teach martial art as I do, I would like to say more to you: Do not get me wrong please Bao, I teach 3 styles and I mastered 3 styles. I do not want to be too humble to you now since you like to coach others a lot. And you like to make up some words and twisted it then ask people for Evil knows reason (not God knows reason here).
For your other writing on your posted message, there are many mistakes as well, I do not want to point them out here since it is not my business. Since you asked me some questions, i have to give a quick answer.
Please do not blame us that I asked my student to post this message for me.
By the way, your name in Chinese has many good meanings, such as Treasure, precious, protect and others...
Hai Yang
p.s.: May I ask a favor from you? I would like to take some of your question from your posts and give answers then show them to my students, to clarify some common misunderstanding or mistakes. Is it ok with you? If so, I will really appreciate it, because you know, sometimes, pointing out mistakes are more helpful to students than showing a good sample only.
I will wait for your answer.
Enjoy!
can you teach that? Maybe you can. Since you are asking this question so maybe you want to improve your skill of teaching. But i have to be direct to you that I cannot and I never did. I only teach students the second style after years of practicing the first style. Or, at least, that the person knows how to separate the different practices from different styles.
techniques or sparring at all, so you want to use Shenfa, the word you even do not know, to fool others. Sorry for my straightness, it is my personality that I can not tolerate your unreasonable hypothesis at all.. . .
I do not want to be too humble to you now since you like to coach others a lot. And you like to make up some words and twisted it then ask people for Evil knows reason (not God knows reason here).
For your other writing on your posted message, there are many mistakes as well, I do not want to point them out here since it is not my business. Since you asked me some questions, i have to give a quick answer.
May I ask a favor from you? I would like to take some of your question from your posts and give answers then show them to my students, to clarify some common misunderstanding or mistakes. Is it ok with you? If so, I will really appreciate it, because you know, sometimes, pointing out mistakes are more helpful to students than showing a good sample only. I will wait for your answer.
David Boxen wrote:Maybe the question is where does intention originate from?
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests