by Chris McKinley on Sun Dec 14, 2008 11:57 am
Hi guys....I heard my name invoked within a magic circle at midnight so I am compelled to appear. Yes, it exists. Yes, it can happen to anyone under duress or any situation in which a strong adrenal response is initiated. Yes, learning to induce it without the adrenal response can be somewhat difficult and usually takes years of practice to achieve anything truly useful beyond a parlor trick. Learning to retain full mental faculties while in that state is even more difficult. Few have the interest. Fewer have the capability. Fewer still have the perseverance.
Ultimately though, apart from Peacedog's perhaps understandable motivations for being interested in this topic, this thread skirts dangerously close to being a part of a recent trend I've noticed here on EF that has nothing to do with him. Namely, that of "magic bullet" threads. Guys starting threads about the existence, relative merit, and how-to instructions on a variety of things that could only be categorized as proverbial magic bullets when it comes to combat. Or, at the very best, as icing on what must already be a superb cake in order to have any functional merit. Again, I'm not referencing Peacedog on this.
It's kinda disappointing if not surprising to see so much of this. People have always been drawn to the appeal of shortcuts and magic bullets. In all likelihood, that appeal is what drew many of us to Kong Foo in the first place. We saw some example, whether in the movies or in meatspace, that made us say, "Cool, I wanna be able to do that!" Later, as we learned the hard way, there's no magic bullet to kung fu, you have to work your ass off to be able to fight effectively. Still, the lesson didn't seem to be completely learned with some us recently. Again, a lot of threads with topics about minutiae that don't matter diddly in a real fight, or are so completely out of our control that it's not worth spending any serious time on them.
Where are the threads on how to improve the results of your training on combat basics? How to improve the efficiency in IMA's notoriously inefficient approach to teaching combat skills? Or, how to be objective when evaluating all the various nonsense that comes across the forum in the guise of new threads when some stuff has merit but most of it is bunko? All of these would be far more useful than to bring up a given magic bullet for the millionth time for discussion, or to ask how hopelessly-long-dead master-from-another-time-and-country # 2716 flexed his pinky toe while practicing standing there.
Discussing artsy nuance is one thing; doing so repetitively at the expense of anything actually useful in a real fight tends to water down the quality of the forum IMO. It's not that certain subjects can't be discussed, nobody's asking for censorship. It's just that they should pop up, and not in batches, only every once in a while as a lark. Most of the time we should be attempting to discuss those aspects of our arts that are most relevant to self-defense and combat in today's world under today's circumstances.
Just kidding....of course we should be discussing pinky toes. I hear Dong Hai Quan had a secret method of placing a higher percentage of his weight over just the right pinky toe that he used to defeat Yang Lu chan and that he only taught to Cheng Ting hua. Or was it Yin fu? Anyway, only the Tianjin Bagua practitioners have it today....everybody else is a charlatan with a fake lineage.
Last edited by Chris McKinley on Sun Dec 14, 2008 12:08 pm, edited 2 times in total.