Re: Xinyiliuhequan curriculum
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2019 1:09 am
Yes, as ‘nicklinjm’ say, I would like to have said, but just came up with this -
I wouldn’t pay to much attention to that writings and sayings, it shows of little knowledge and somewhat disrespect of the other XYQ.
That Xingyiquan has 12 animal shapes instead of ten,and the 10 was originally 6, which steam from the three ‘fists’ does not mean ‘more is less’, in this case....or anyway should not mean that.
Before any knowledgeable teacher throw students into all the animal shapes one has to ingrain the core practice of the fundamentals, it’s a methodically step by step process in all the XYQans
But anyway i myself has shortcomings on the subject, i do see quite a few similarities to the point I would say XYLHQ and XYQ are basically the same.
Both work with force on the vertical and horizontal plane, while the slight difference I think I can detect is that xylh is slightly more pronounced toward the vertical, while xyq on the horizontal plane....As I said I only so far have a couple of months of xylh practice to compare with my other stuff’s of many years......So probably nothing to pay attention to here too
I wouldn’t pay to much attention to that writings and sayings, it shows of little knowledge and somewhat disrespect of the other XYQ.
That Xingyiquan has 12 animal shapes instead of ten,and the 10 was originally 6, which steam from the three ‘fists’ does not mean ‘more is less’, in this case....or anyway should not mean that.
Before any knowledgeable teacher throw students into all the animal shapes one has to ingrain the core practice of the fundamentals, it’s a methodically step by step process in all the XYQans
But anyway i myself has shortcomings on the subject, i do see quite a few similarities to the point I would say XYLHQ and XYQ are basically the same.
Both work with force on the vertical and horizontal plane, while the slight difference I think I can detect is that xylh is slightly more pronounced toward the vertical, while xyq on the horizontal plane....As I said I only so far have a couple of months of xylh practice to compare with my other stuff’s of many years......So probably nothing to pay attention to here too