Page 1 of 3

Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2022 9:10 am
by GrahamB
My guest in this episode is Michael Babin a Tai Chi practitioner from Ottawa, Canada who has been teaching Tai Chi since the 1980s. He’s primarily a Yang style practitioner, but also does a bit of Sun style Tai Chi on the side. Michael is now officially retired from running his own school, but still keeps his hand in training 3 or 4 times a week with his old students.

In our discussion we talk a lot about the problems associated with teaching Tai Chi and what the Tai Chi scene was like in Canada in the 90s and how things have changed compared to today. We also chat about the various Tai Chi teachers Michael has trained under over the years including Tim Cartmell, Erle Montaigue and Sam Masich.

Michael has recently started a YouTube channel where you can see him teaching and performing Tai Chi, which you can find at: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCp-_4T ... brTOF0WBow


Podcast: https://anchor.fm/graham47/episodes/Ep- ... 0s-e1hl3ke

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2022 8:27 am
by Formosa Neijia

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dds-KE16kAQ
This standardized choreography was designed for competition purposes in China as well as to be a good beginner's form and is based mostly on Yang-style theory and structure. Though there are no kicks, important postures are done on both sides and several key movements are done mirror-image which means that practising this form regularly can help you understand those postures from a different perspective than usually done in the longer sets. It also takes less physical space than the traditional long forms and less time to perform one repetition. Anyone can find the 3-5 minutes a couple of times a day to loosen their body and reinforce good postural habits.

I am demonstrating the older 16 posture [Beijing] choreography which should not to be confused with the more recent 16 Posture Traditional Yang Form released around 2010. I have done both in the Yang style and actually prefer this older version, perhaps because I think the traditional sets shouldn't be "tinkered with" or "dumbing-down" in any way. As with the 16 Form Sword Set , the 16 Form Empty Hands Set is sometimes said to have 18 parts but that's just because some instructors identify the first and last postures numerically instead of calling them the Opening and Closing Movements.

The solo sword form takes less space and athletic ability compared to the longer, more traditional sword sets. It remains a very good introduction to the study of the beauty and sophistication of the solo usage of the Chinese double-edge sword.

If I still taught group or private classes, these are the two sequences that I would use for the average beginner.


Nice. I'm looking forward to listening to the podcast later.

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2022 1:15 pm
by wayne hansen
Before you listen to the podcast please go to his YouTube page for context

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2022 4:39 pm
by origami_itto
What is it with these heavy steps?

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 9:34 am
by Formosa Neijia
origami_itto wrote:What is it with these heavy steps?


Not everyone wants to be lite in the loafers. More people should try it

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 9:47 am
by origami_itto
Formosa Neijia wrote:
origami_itto wrote:What is it with these heavy steps?


Not everyone wants to be lite in the loafers. More people should try it


Is that some sort of homophobic slur? In 2022 you're still rockin' that sort of hate? Classy.

Polyamorous pansexuals have WAY more fun.

In Taijiquan, it is generally considered an error to commit your weight before the foot is securely placed. I would be interested to hear his explanation for why he falls into his step. Good example around 0:19-0:21

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 11:19 am
by Michael Babin
Origami.ito

Re: "What is it with those heavy steps?"

Not sure what you mean and I suppose I could also say that Yang taiji solo form should be a "weighty issue" in the sense of not being too light and fluffy. :)

More likely you can detect the effect of my being 70 and having had a total hip-replacement on one side more than a decade ago as well as a damaged knee on the other leg. Funny how decades of a variety of martial arts practise can play havoc with an aging carcass. Well, not funny as in "ha-ha".

Those short forms on my channel are ok for the average middle class "taiji for health" beginners. I'm not trying to sell my services anymore and I won't be posting videos of the solo forms I do practise regularly as my own daily training is divided up into a variety of bagua forms as well as one long and two medium-length Yang-style forms with their accompanying sword forms. Nor will I be posting Yang taiji martial or push-hands stuff as most of what is shown on youtube and elsewhere -- including the stuff I do -- is sad from a fighting perspective when taken out of context. No one can learn anything martially relevant from those kind of instructional videos in any case unless they are already skillful in a related style/discipline.

Where online can we see your solo form work?

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 12:17 pm
by origami_itto
Michael Babin wrote:Origami.ito

Re: "What is it with those heavy steps?"

Not sure what you mean and I suppose I could also say that Yang taiji solo form should be a "weighty issue" in the sense of not being too light and fluffy. :)

More likely you can detect the effect of my being 70 and having had a total hip-replacement on one side more than a decade ago as well as a damaged knee on the other leg. Funny how decades of a variety of martial arts practise can play havoc with an aging carcass. Well, not funny as in "ha-ha".

Those short forms on my channel are ok for the average middle class "taiji for health" beginners. I'm not trying to sell my services anymore and I won't be posting videos of the solo forms I do practise regularly as my own daily training is divided up into a variety of bagua forms as well as one long and two medium-length Yang-style forms with their accompanying sword forms. Nor will I be posting Yang taiji martial or push-hands stuff as most of what is shown on youtube and elsewhere -- including the stuff I do -- is sad from a fighting perspective when taken out of context. No one can learn anything martially relevant from those kind of instructional videos in any case unless they are already skillful in a related style/discipline.

Where online can we see your solo form work?


Hello Michael! I appreciate your response.

I don't post videos. Nothing worth looking at, though I might share the first section of the Dong Simplified form once I've got the sequence dialed in.

What I mean is that when you step there it appears there is a moment where your weight is behind your foot but your foot is not in contact with the ground, as it makes contact you're bringing that weight into the ground at the same time.

The way I was taught to step, in Taijiquan specifically, was "like a cat" or as walking on a frozen lake.

The foot makes contact empty as if testing the surface of the lake for slipperiness or to make sure it will take your weight, and then the weight is moved into the leg.

This IS different than some of the stepping I'm familiar with in Bagua and Xingyi but what you're doing seems less intentional and precise than what I would expect those techniques to appear.

Injuries are a gift! They tell us when we're doing it wrong, lol. I had ACL replacement in 2019 for a ligament that was severed completely in 2009. It was a very instructive period lol.

I don't have any video of myself, but luckily at this point we have access to a lot of great films of truly proficient masters to refer to for comparison.

Look at how Dong Ying Jie steps between 0:26 - 0:33, that's what I'm referring to.
https://youtu.be/b4WwTVNqXAk?t=26
2:35 or so is a GREAT example due to the angle
https://youtu.be/b4WwTVNqXAk?t=155


Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 1:05 pm
by wayne hansen
I see the ghost of erle montague pushing him on every step

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 1:10 pm
by origami_itto
wayne hansen wrote:I see the ghost of erle montague pushing him on every step

Lol, Micheal or Dong Yingjie?

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 1:34 pm
by wayne hansen
The Tung Dong family has my greatest respect

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 2:34 pm
by johnwang
origami_itto wrote:The way I was taught to step, in Taijiquan specifically, was "like a cat" or as walking on a frozen lake.

Like to walk on a frozen lake is the correct training. But I don't think Yang Taiji emphasizes on this.

In the following clip, CMC dropped his left heel on the ground first in his single whip.

If it's

- on a frozen lake, his left foot would break the ice and sank.
- in a fight, his opponent would scoop or sweep his left leading leg and make him to fall.

This is a good example that when Yang Taiji becomes "for health only", people no longer follow the combat guideline any more.

Image

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 2:36 pm
by origami_itto
wayne hansen wrote:The Tung Dong family has my greatest respect

I'll pass it along when we speak.

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 2:45 pm
by GrahamB
How do you step on ice without breaking it then? ( Apart from wearing tennis rackets as shoes). Obviously a flat foot would spread the weight more evenly, but CMC is not putting whole body weight on his heel.... I'm more inclined to think that on ice he would simply slip - because less surface area is contact with the ice.

Re: Ep 12: Michael Babin on teaching Tai Chi in the 90s

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2022 2:49 pm
by johnwang
GrahamB wrote:How do you step on ice without breaking it then? ( Apart from wearing tennis rackets as shoes).

- Toes down first, or
- flat foot landing, or
- flat foot sliding.