Trip wrote:What's with all this extra stuff you're bring up?
the "inner door secret' stuff?
and I'm putting people on a pedestal
I don't get it.
You're bring up stuff that is not in my post.
Putting people on a pedestal seems to be your thing.
You're the one always talking about how great Huang is
and Adam is, admiring PK.
Okay Fine, Great. You like them.
I've never once got on you about it.
Nothing like that has been in my post
I'm replying to only what Charlie is saying about specific things about specific teachers,
that they didn't say this and they wouldn't post that cause they don't want people to have it.
And, they deliberately put out incorrect pictures and videos, that are deliberately incorrect.
And, nobody gets to say to him...Huh?
I didn't add opinion
I'm posting clearly what those specific teachers did say.
You seem to being ignoring what he's saying about others without Charlie showing a shred of proof.
Odd.
Next he'll say "Chengfu's 10 Important Points are deliberately misleading."
And, if somebody asks dares ask him to clarify,
"Well what in the 10 Important Points are deliberately misleading?"
You'll jump to his defense.
"It's funny how people put the 10 Important point on a pedestal."
It's the mark of a developed mind to consider ideas without necessarily accepting them. Pull em in, mull em around a bit.
I'm not sure who you're talking to in this post, but it seems like one of us hit a nerve.
I'm not defending Charlie, just being polite. I'm not attacking you, just discussing how people are dishonest when money is involved. I've been studying Yang style for over 20 years, I have a great deal of respect for what YCF and CMC contributed to the dissemination of the art, without which I would have never known of it. I have a great deal of respect for their skill and method.
But they lied, man, just straight up told a falsehood in print in this same book that you are using as proof that they are transmitting the complete and accurate system.
Now, consider for a second this... We know that there is more to Taijiquan than the long form and basic push hands drills. So if he is saying that this book contains "the complete methodology of form and function into a complete volume, including the fundamental training method" that seems a bit of a stretch, particularly when later in the same text he says he's intending to publish more details in a second book that didn't get written.
It's sales patter. Have you ever opened a Koran and looked at the first page. It's usually something to the effect of "This translation was prepared by Muhammed Ibn Al Shalod. It is the most accurate and complete translation of the Koran ever attempted. No other translation of the Koran should ever be necesarry to own. In fact you should buy two of them to fully honor the greatness of this translation by Muhammed Ibn Al Shalod, you can keep one in the study and one by your bedside, and then get some for the car and kitchen too. You never want to be further than arm's reach away from a Koran translated by Muhammed Ibn Al Shalod."
Now the ten important points.... I'm gonna have to ask you to take a seat for this one.
In the book Dong Ying Jie wrote for him, there were 20 points. Two lists of ten that the ten we know today were drawn from both of them. The other ten were just tossed out. The ones that were lost were the ones that involved more physically strenuous training, such as "the thigh should be parallel to the floor".
So the "ten points" are just a package for the entry level basic health maintenance crowd that they were hawking the system to. The dilettantes and old folks with money that would take that money elsewhere if you told them to get in a horse stance.
It's sales and marketing, just like most of what people criticize about Adam Mizner. A hundred years from now he'll be the new Yang Cheng Fu and they'll be combing over his statements arguing over the bullshit that his contemporaries are currently rolling their eyes about.
Do I think they deliberately lied about things to hide secrets? I dunno, maybe, I don't trust em. I trust my hands and feet and eyes and heart. The rest is just trimming on the tree. It's my realm instead of WWII or Star Wars or Marvel or whatever. My area of ever increasing trivial knowledge.