wayne hansen wrote:Untruthful YCF and CMC
That’s one for the books
I’ll take that as just another hissy fit of little relevance
Quick question- do you have a daily qigong or neigong?
Steve James wrote:Afa YCF's lies and misstatements, people make up childhood memories all the time. Maybe he really thought it happened?
wayne hansen wrote:The above translation may be in error
I doubt YCF would talk about seeing his dead grandfather train if everyone knew they did not live at the same time
Who is writing that
Trip wrote:. . . .
Yang Jun & Yang Zhenduo pass on clear updated info . . . .
Steve James wrote:Well, if YCF couldn't have known when his grandfather died, then it's possible his father (or some other family member) told him that story. I was alive when my grandfather died, so I know the date. My son doesn't. If I told him that he met my grandmother, he'd believe it.
Otoh, worst case, he made up the story to ... what, exactly? He was already the public face of Yang style. I'm not sure his anecdote gave him more credibility, but that's the worst reason I can think of. If that's the worst thing I can say about him, meh, especially if that's his worst lie.
wayne hansen wrote:All translations are a lie
Is there any film of Swaim doing tai chi
From Yang Ch'eng-fu's
Complete Principles
and Applications
of T'ai-chi ch'iian
Yang Ch'eng-fu,
T'ai-chi ch 'iian t 'i-yung ch 'uan-shu
(Complete principles and
applications of T'ai-chi chiian),
Taipei : Chung-hua wu-shu
ch'u-pan-she, 1975
(first edition, 1934) .
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests