Does Shanxi XY do a Tan Toi set?
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2008 11:08 pm
After watching hundreds of different versions from various provinces in China tonight of the 10 tan toi and 12 tan toi, I thought that the movements seemed familiar (other than having done these forms since the late 1970s).
Indeed, they matched closely, with some minor variation, in form and function to the Yue Shi ba Fan Shou set, and then after looking at dozens of tapes of that set, I suddenly knew where I had seen those movements before as well, and I realized that the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set of 12 rows, is just another way to do the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou and the 10 & 12 tan toi sets.
Each row in the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set was in the same order as the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou sets and these were in the same order as the 12 Roads of the Shanxi XY Lian Huan Set.
That was really weird to see! I did the forms myself and could easily interchange from each of the three styles by knowing which road I was on.
So, somewhere between the three styles there was some exchanging being done.
Unless both the Shandong based Tan toi sets and the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set are both based on the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou set?
That's the more plausible explanation?
In essence, these three sets are the same in sequence and function of each road. that's too much of a coincidence.
Indeed, they matched closely, with some minor variation, in form and function to the Yue Shi ba Fan Shou set, and then after looking at dozens of tapes of that set, I suddenly knew where I had seen those movements before as well, and I realized that the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set of 12 rows, is just another way to do the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou and the 10 & 12 tan toi sets.
Each row in the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set was in the same order as the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou sets and these were in the same order as the 12 Roads of the Shanxi XY Lian Huan Set.
That was really weird to see! I did the forms myself and could easily interchange from each of the three styles by knowing which road I was on.
So, somewhere between the three styles there was some exchanging being done.
Unless both the Shandong based Tan toi sets and the Shanxi XY Lian Huan set are both based on the Yue Shi Ba Fan Shou set?
That's the more plausible explanation?
In essence, these three sets are the same in sequence and function of each road. that's too much of a coincidence.