Page 1 of 1

bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Sun Aug 19, 2018 9:21 pm
by everything

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Mon Aug 20, 2018 6:04 am
by windwalker
nice perspective from an old masters point of view


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktkHf5t6gMw

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Tue Aug 21, 2018 8:09 pm
by everything
oh thanks for part 2

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Tue Aug 28, 2018 8:39 am
by Overlord
I totally agree with “no showing” and some of old school sayings he would like to share. And I am a Xingyi guy.
But hearing his puffy breathing and his claim to kick Muaythai ass make me question his sanity.
If he cannot subdue an any opponent within 3 secs he will be destroyed given his physical plight and age.
Very sad and embarrassing to see claims like this from a Xingyi teacher without any humility or reservation.

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Tue Aug 28, 2018 9:03 am
by Bao
Overlord wrote:If he cannot subdue an any opponent within 3 secs he will be destroyed given his physical plight and age.
Very sad and embarrassing to see claims like this from a Xingyi teacher without any humility or reservation.


When he has the gloves on, he keep his arms hanging down. Seems like lack of experience. He would last no more than five seconds if he don’t know how to keep his arms up. I like a lot of what he says though... Maybe he knows what he is doing, maybe not.... I prefer to believe in him. :)

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Tue Aug 28, 2018 5:06 pm
by everything
^^^ yeah.

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Tue Aug 28, 2018 11:18 pm
by Trick
Bao wrote:
Overlord wrote:If he cannot subdue an any opponent within 3 secs he will be destroyed given his physical plight and age.
Very sad and embarrassing to see claims like this from a Xingyi teacher without any humility or reservation.


When he has the gloves on, he keep his arms hanging down. Seems like lack of experience. He would last no more than five seconds if he don’t know how to keep his arms up. I like a lot of what he says though... Maybe he knows what he is doing, maybe not.... I prefer to believe in him. :)

The guard is in the head. Watch some Roy Jones Jr in his prime fights for example. Now I’m not comparing the guy in the vid with the boxer.

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Wed Aug 29, 2018 12:41 am
by Bao
Trick wrote:The guard is in the head. Watch some Roy Jones Jr in his prime fights for example. Now I’m not comparing the guy in the vid with the boxer.


That means that you will guard with your head. There’s a distance between low and high and there is always a cognitive delay. This is just how the human brain function and we can’t do anything about it. Sparring rule number one: always keep your hands up. Boxers can keep their guard down, but most of them do it as a calculated risk while using footwork, bobbing etc. That’s a part of the game plan.

Will try to search better later but there’s a good vid on the YouTube demonstrating the difference between having hands high and low and how hard it is to defend yourself from a straight lead without keeping your hand already high. There’s a huge difference. So you can keep your guard in your head or minimize the risks. That’s your own choice.

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Wed Aug 29, 2018 3:38 am
by Trick
Bao wrote:
Trick wrote:The guard is in the head. Watch some Roy Jones Jr in his prime fights for example. Now I’m not comparing the guy in the vid with the boxer.


That means that you will guard with your head. There’s a distance between low and high and there is always a cognitive delay. This is just how the human brain function and we can’t do anything about it. Sparring rule number one: always keep your hands up. Boxers can keep their guard down, but most of them do it as a calculated risk while using footwork, bobbing etc. That’s a part of the game plan.

Will try to search better later but there’s a good vid on the YouTube demonstrating the difference between having hands high and low and how hard it is to defend yourself from a straight lead without keeping your hand already high. There’s a huge difference. So you can keep your guard in your head or minimize the risks. That’s your own choice.

Distance and timing, listening energy(feeling) from distance(no touch). I even think you have posted a few quotes from Li Yaxuan’s thoughts/writings about this. Of course one have to have free sparred(fought) at least a couple of times to catch some understanding of it. Hands up, hands down or somewhere in between may shifts naturally with how the sense/feel of the opponent move. And also to be able to throw a good punch from high, low or anywhere in between is good skill to have at hand.....But yes “rule number one” for sure is what one learn from day one in a boxing gym, and it’s a good advice because in the ring most will get hit in the head....a lot.

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Wed Aug 29, 2018 3:42 am
by marvin8

Re: bagua xingyi taiji, do not "express energy"

PostPosted: Wed Aug 29, 2018 8:20 am
by origami_itto




I thought it looked familiar. :)

I actually wound up finally meeting Mike Graves last weekend at the quarterly Texas Meetup. Helluva guy. Great skills.