the rum soaked fist: internal martial arts forum

2 month ago I would thought this is fake..... Now i beg a differ.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6sFyCdk ... re=related

what changed your mind.....i think he has the goods myself

HAhaha.... I was just typing the same thing Derek...

Lewitt

feihua

That he has the goods is IMO hardly evinced by the drama of this clip with prancing, tip toeing, or back-leaning 'actors' who are obviously playing to the audience.

somatai wrote:what changed your mind.....i think he has the goods myself

i met his grand grand student.....

he had me doing the same type of falls/flying plus more while he is standing in a normal stance (not bow arrow stance, just two feet parallel at shoulder width.)

any ideas on how he did it?

S

iwalkthecircle wrote:2 month ago I would thought this is fake..... Now i beg a differ.

Congratulation iwalkthecircle, your reality has now opened up to new possibilities . It's really rare to encounter such individuals with such ability. I had a similar experience a couple of years back and now I seek the soft skills of taijiquan.

For those who have not experience such an ability, it is best (most logical) to dismiss such things (that's what I did, i use to think this kind of stuff was fake), because such things make no sense unless it is felt personally. To talk/write/debate/argue about it with people who have not gone through an equivalent encounter is a waste of time.

the clip had nothing to do with my opinion

shawnsegler wrote:any ideas on how he did it?

S

his words were sung and tinJin(relaxed by dropping wt & having sensitive skill.)

he gave me couple of ideas/clues, I had a little success getting it. still trying out, when I get it maybe people will say it is fake.

somatai wrote:the clip had nothing to do with my opinion

do you know his students or grand students?


from what I gathered in Taiwan about half of MA people thinks that Master Huang Sheng Shyan is fake.....

Since something like 90 percent of people I meet in general are a little slow, and if you cut that into 50 percent and then make them MA'ists who are a notoriously crazy/bigoted group, then I'd have to ask myself why anyone would care what that 50 percent was thinking.

Always best to feel for yourself anyhow.

S

iwalkthecircle wrote:from what I gathered in Taiwan about half of MA people thinks that Master Huang Sheng Shyan is fake.....

I think some of those people opinions are shaded by politics (e.g. "he's doing white crane"). shawnsegler's is right in advising it's best to feel for oneself.

dragontigerpalm wrote:That he has the goods is IMO hardly evinced by the drama of this clip with prancing, tip toeing, or back-leaning 'actors' who are obviously playing to the audience.

Yes. Unfortunately you're going to find that no one wants to address the points that you raised. The little "Peter Pan" leap they do before touching Huang, the blatantly obvious back lean of some of the students, etc. are things that won't be discussed.

Dave C.

My doubt is if Huang do have some LKJ skill but his students exaggerate it, or if it is 100% hypnosis, or worse a blatant farce.