retreats108 wrote:crazy Friday-night hooligan.....using his Ksatriya Silat art, which as I mentioned, has kept him alive in countless real fights against sharp things, heavy blunt things, projectile things and other stuff that I won't put here due to legal reasons.
retreats108 wrote:Wayne, the video is what it is.
...
Introduce yourself, video what you do, make it an exchange - not simply a demand by an unknown person....
Tiga Pukul wrote:Some decent Silat in the movie there. I recognize typical Cimande drills and tactics. However i miss a bit (perhaps done deliberately) the most essential part of good Silat, which is Langkah (i.e. Footwork). Although the hard hitting on arm (limb descruction) is typical of Cimande, in the end footwork is more important. A bit like the boxer. We have several people of comparative skill in Holland so it looks quite familiar :). Not quite sure why he would call it also 'pukulan', but that discussion is a bit of a hornets' nest in Silat.
Bhassler wrote:Tiga Pukul wrote:Some decent Silat in the movie there. I recognize typical Cimande drills and tactics. However i miss a bit (perhaps done deliberately) the most essential part of good Silat, which is Langkah (i.e. Footwork). Although the hard hitting on arm (limb descruction) is typical of Cimande, in the end footwork is more important. A bit like the boxer. We have several people of comparative skill in Holland so it looks quite familiar . Not quite sure why he would call it also 'pukulan', but that discussion is a bit of a hornets' nest in Silat.
I thought that 'pukulan' (loosely) meant 'hitting'-- going by that interpretation, isn't the video exactly what it says it is? I.E. a demonstration of some of the hitting concepts without worrying about footwork, etc?
but that discussion is a bit of a hornets' nest in Silat.
discussion is a bit of a hornets' nest in Silat.
retreats108 wrote:Would you walk into someone's dojo and instantly demand to see them demonstrate all kinds of applications?
retreats108 wrote:it is just my view on internet etiquette, maybe its too much to hope for !
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 76 guests