Doc Stier wrote:the vast majority of physically violent assaults occur suddenly and unexpectedly, oftentimes through ambush from a hidden position, from strangers unknown to the target individual. Any such assailant could potentially possess fighting abilities of equal or greater skill than their intended victim
That's kind of the whole point of why I say it's irrelevant. Everything in the video starts from breaking the opponent's guard in a face to face confrontation. An ambush is unlikely to be hands up, face to face. You either have to pre-empt the situation (by avoidance, preferably, not the hit-first 'pre-emptive strike' BS that gets bandied about in the SD community), or start from a recovery position where you're already out of position and eating punches (if you're lucky).
Doc Stier wrote:To assume as you apparently do that you will always be aware of an impending assault and thereby always be prepared to successfully deal with it effectively seems like an unrealistic expectation, which could result in an unfortunate outcome in the real world of street defense.
Most stuff is pretty easy to avoid-- by the time it gets physical or an attack is launched, you've already fucked up in terms of your self defense skills. 99.999% of all violence falls into predictable patterns. The idea of stuff coming out of nowhere is a myth born of ignorance and the unwillingness of people to acknowledge that they can (and probably should) recognize the possibility of violence in their safe little worlds and get some basic education by way of preparation. Everyone has bad days and can be caught off guard, etc. and there may be some horrific situation where someone chooses to intervene in a violent scenario, and in those cases having physical skills ratchets way up in importance-- but that's still a far cry from anything relevant to the video in the OP.