Page 5 of 5

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 6:12 pm
by cloudz
the devil is in the detail

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 6:15 pm
by Fubo
wayne hansen wrote:All though not common there were teachers of these arts in the west when I started in 73
Tim didn’t go to Taiwan until 84 so I’m not sure what you mean by the earliest


I never said Tim was the "earliest".

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Mon Nov 21, 2022 7:24 pm
by Bob
In his own words:

6:20 and beyond gives you a good idea how he has evolved

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=de3HLG681bk

Rolled Up Episode 27: The Never ending path of a martial artist with Tim Cartmell


Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Sun Jan 08, 2023 7:05 pm
by leftwose
I've been gone for years but it is so nice to find some stability in these trying times. Good to see RSF is and will always be RSF

.conal.

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 12:46 am
by yeniseri
Mr Cartmell has shown that he is, and has always been an excellent competitor and has competed with the best of many martial practitioners, regardless of style, something that few of us, including myself have never done when compard to his ability to mix it up with anyone. I can say that in Taiwan, there were central figures who studied under one another and they were numerous. Here are sonme names: Luo Dexiu, Zhang JUnfeng, Hong YIxang and a host of others under a similar umbrella.

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 4:33 am
by wayne hansen
Can’t quite workout what you are saying there

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 10:59 pm
by Sea.Wolf.Forge
wayne hansen wrote:Can’t quite workout what you are saying there


I'm late to this party, Tim trained alongside my instructor with his instructor in Taiwan - I was told by my instructor when I asked that he was legit so I believe it as I've never met the man and that he has a black belt in BJJ is an accomplishment I respect but your personal mileage with it may vary.

As for the rest of the conversation - didn't see this particular video, don't really care. I saw that Wayne asked about his fight record - in what universe does a TMA stylist care about a fight record? Do you mean MMA? Kickboxing? Back alley Bei Mo? Barfights? Pick a lane.

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 1:05 am
by wayne hansen
I can’t be bothered going back
I think I was responding to the statement that someone said he was a great fighter
So I asked about his fights

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 11:49 pm
by Sea.Wolf.Forge
wayne hansen wrote:I can’t be bothered going back
I think I was responding to the statement that someone said he was a great fighter
So I asked about his fights


::)

Re: Tim Cartmell Bagua and Xingyi forms

PostPosted: Mon Jan 16, 2023 7:55 am
by origami_itto
wayne hansen wrote:I can’t be bothered going back
I think I was responding to the statement that someone said he was a great fighter
So I asked about his fights


http://www.shenwu.com/background.htm

You competed in some full contact tournaments in Taiwan. What did you learn from this experience?

After I had been training in Taiwan about six months, my Xing Yi Quan teacher entered me in a full contact tournament. Though I lost, it was an enlightening experience for me. Although there were few rules in these matches, there was a certain strategy that applied, much different from a street fight for example. Many of the Chinese fighters are extremely tough, and they usuallv dominate the international competitions there. Competing with them I gained valuable experience and insight into my own methods of training. I went back to revise my training based on my experiences and, a few months later, I entered another full contact competition. The organizers put me up into the light heavyweight division although at the time I was only 150 lbs. I took first place in the division and came through without injury. This experience was very valuable as it indicated my training methods were on the right track. The next year I entered one of the larger international tournaments. I won again, taking first place in the middleweight division. I feel these competitions gave me a wealth of valuable experience. I think the most important lessons I learned from these fights was that you can never practice the basics too much. You need to be a well rounded fighter, but knowing a thousand techniques you can do beautifully when there is no real pressure is not nearly as valuable as mastering a few techniques you can actually use in a real fight. It is, however, vital to be exposed to all areas of fighting. In order to be able to maintain mental calm and physical relaxation under pressure, you must be proficient in striking, wrestling and grappling arts. Sparring with skilled, non-cooperative opponents is a must if you hope to be able to use your art in a real fight. Finally, your mind-set and attitude will almost always prove to be the ultimate determinate of your victory or defeat.