by Bao on Fri Jan 02, 2009 5:07 pm
Very nice indeed.
Form: I dont like it very much. It seems to be a little bit limp, or "lazy". No "twist and stretch"-quality of the limbs, so I see no classical bagua shenfa. But my teacher is all to lazy as well, and with his knowlegde he should know to practice with a more strict shen fa. But he is sufferening from his high belief in relaxation - a kind of CMC and (late)SLT-syndrome, which is very good for taijiquan, but In my own personal wiev, not for bagua, I believe that bagua form should be practiced in a highly technical manner, and the technical aspects of shen fa should be "over emphasised" just like bagua shen fa itself is built on over-emphasising certain aspect. (And that is the very reason why I dont even practice bagua anymore.)
Apps: What I really like is the timing. If you compare with many similar demos, what often disturbs me is the overly aggressive approach. It's not that aggression is wrong. But I think some people are so eager to show the martial usage, so they forget about calmness and timing. A good physical and mental balance, calmness, relaxation - this is what gives you a sense of control over a situation and make sure you can rely on good timing.
In this sense, this vid is definitively better than most, if you compare it with BKF, E. Montague and many other demonstrations. If you dont understand what I mean, please take a look at clips of Wang Peisheng or Xie Peixi, two people known to have been most excellent fighters. These and other real fighters can move with great speed, but there is always a very calm focusing. Think of this as the focus of a cat before attacking a prey, and compare this with the hysterical "montaguesque" - non-timing no-control approach, and you can easily see understand the importance of a calm focused mind that stay calm and focused even when exploding into a fast attack... I think this guy is heading for something really good.
Last edited by
Bao on Sat Jan 03, 2009 3:55 am, edited 2 times in total.
Thoughts on Tai Chi (My Tai Chi blog)
-
Storms make oaks take deeper root. -George Herbert
-
To affect the quality of the day, is the highest of all arts! -Walden Thoreau