Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Rum, beer, women, movies, nice websites, gaming, etc., without interrupting the flow of martial threads.

Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Tom on Wed Nov 25, 2020 4:54 pm

Thanks to Graham for the article link in the Xinjiang thread--and on his great blog http://www.thetaichinotebook.com. I think what's going on in Nei Mongol deserves its own thread.

https://www.bloodyelbow.com/2020/11/17/21571053/bokh-wrestling-and-the-cultural-genocide-in-inner-mongolia

Bökh wrestling, and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Bökh wrestlers open up to Bloody Elbow, saying the People’s Republic of China is trying to erase their culture and violate their rights.

By Chris Massari Nov 17, 2020, 10:00am EST

From the 1970s up to today, the People’s Republic of China has had a meteoric resurgence back to global prominence, establishing itself to be firmly part of what many believe to be this new era of world superpowers. The country is breaking free from their Century of Humiliation and back to a historical norm of the Middle Kingdom’s global economic dominance.

Although China’s return to prominence has not been without setbacks. As the eyes of the world become more fixated on the People’s Republic, China has met increasing and continuing justified criticisms for human rights violations, regional aggression, cybercrimes, and general practices that do not fit with modern morality.

Currently, as the global community increases pressure on China for its treatment of the Muslim minority Uyghurs in their Northwest region and the PRC’s clampdown on democratically fueled protests in Hong Kong, China has continued to expand its reach despite rising scrutiny.

The most recent addition to this growing list concerns the PRC’s seeming campaign to violate cultural rights, legal treaties, and history itself within their autonomous region of Inner Mongolia.


In increased attempts to force ethnic minority assimilation to the majority Han Chinese culture under Chinese borders, the People’s Republic has implemented a new policy replacing the 800-year-old Mongolian-language within Inner Mongolian school textbooks, with Chinese Mandarin. This same policy was enacted in the autonomous regions of Tibet and Xinjiang in 2017, “where the elimination of local languages in schools have been followed within two decades by forced cultural assimilation and labor camps, as China sheds decades of sponsoring independent ethnicities to bring them under the One China model.”

As a result, China’s new policy has caused mass protests across Inner Mongolia in response, from school children protesting with chants of “Our mother language is Mongolian!” and “We are Mongolian until death!” to parents attempting to pull their children from schools that have caused clashes with police. In one instance, it’s been reported that a student passed away after leaping from a fourth-floor window of a boarding school near the city of Tongliao, as their parents and police scuffled outside.

Across this region, parents and students have refused to attend classes and at least 130 people have already been detained or arrested in response to the protests and “an estimated 8,000-10,000 [ethnic] Mongolians have been placed under some form of police custody since late August,” says the New York-based Southern Mongolia Human Rights Information Center (SMHRIC) in a statement, which has included elderly people, pregnant women, and middle school students. Police have even entered Mongolian homes and gone as far as “making them sign pledges to not speak against the bilingual program anymore,” says the Los Angeles Times as fears of cultural genocide spread across Inner Mongolia.

Alice Su, a United States reporter, was “grabbed by the throat and pushed into a cell and held for more than four hours before being forced to leave the area in northern China [Inner Mongolia],” after being taken to a police station by plainclothesmen, even after identifying herself as an accredited journalist and was not allowed to call the U.S. Embassy. Hohhot, the region’s capital, has denied using force or detaining an American reporter.

MONGOLIA-CHINA-DIPLOMACY-RIGHTS

Image

Protestors hold banners and wave the Mongolian flag during a protest in Ulaanbaatar, the capital of Mongolia, against Chinese policies in the neighbouring Chinese province of Inner Mongolia on October 1, 2020 Photo by BYAMBASUREN BYAMBA-OCHIR/AFP via Getty Images

Outside of the school’s systems and parents, these protests have also had a profound effect on all levels within Inner Mongolia, including athletes of the region’s national sport Mongolian Bökh or Mongolian wrestling, refusing to compete and protesting the policy as well.

“Every Mongolian is very hurt by the current situation. The wrestlers have lost their original confidence and faith and are unable to concentrate on their lives or careers,” says an Inner Mongolian wrestler, who will be referred to in this article as, Oh.

Individuals interviewed for this article will be given pseudo names and referred to without gender, to protect their safety due to concerns of retaliation from the PRC for speaking out about this policy and unfolding circumstances within the region.


Oh, who has already been threatened with arrest by Chinese intelligence services, says the Naadams (traditional festivals in Mongolia for wrestling competitions) are facing direct threat from the unrest, stating, “Because the government fears a high concentration of Mongolians, there are fewer people and fewer opportunities to attend and hold Naadam. Now, people are more focused on preserving our culture and language than Naadam.”

A second wrestler provided their own opinion about what is happening in Inner Mongolia and will also remain nameless. They will be referred to as Em. Unlike Oh, Em does not have roots in Inner Mongolia and provides an outsider’s perspective as a competitor living in the region but was not born there.

Em states, “The recent protests have indeed affected Naadam. For a few weeks, they canceled all the Naadams to protest. Many of the heaviest protestors are wrestlers from the Xilingol region of Inner Mongolia. This has left an emptiness in the atmosphere that is filled with sadness, depression, anger, and frustration.”

Another Inner Mongolian wrestler, who will be called Aitch, put it in more straightforward terms.

“Wrestlers have stopped wrestling, and most of them feel ‘if we lose our language, what is the point of becoming a famous wrestler? If we lose our culture, our language, then Bökh simply won’t exist one day. So, what is the point?’

“Every part of our culture influences all of our wrestlers and all of them feel a real darkness is coming. We refuse to wrestle and don’t want to put our wrestling jacket on. We refuse to have fun blindly. If we don’t have our language, then we simply won’t have our culture and it will cause Bökh to disappear one day. Bökh and the Mongolian culture are too deeply connected for one to go on without the other independently.”

Aitch has also faced reprisal for involvement in these protests, and is facing termination due to resistance to this new policy.


Image

Chinggis Khaan Khuree Ger Camp
Bökh wrestlers from Inner Mongolia Getty Images


WHY DOES IT MATTER?
The implementation of this policy is damaging to not only Mongolian culture, but it sets a precedence that could result in “total destruction of language, culture, and identity of all ethnic minorities” within China, said Enghebatu Togochog, director of the New York-based Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Centre. “All Mongolians feel that losing your language means losing your children and our future,” says Togochog.

Oh, echoes this sentiment, “Every link of Mongolia is linked with Mongolian culture. Language is the carrier of culture, an important conductor for the transmission of it. If we lose the language, we have lost the most important part of our culture.


“Our biggest fear is losing the grassland, losing the culture, eventually being assimilated, becoming part of the history like the Manchu, becoming displays in a museum,” Oh says. “In the end, no one would know we were there, and worse yet, others would call us Han (Chinese)! We are Mongolians. We have Mongolian culture. We have Mongolian blood! We love our life and we don’t want to accept this ending, so we will stick it out.”

Currently, Inner Mongolia is the only place where the traditional 800-year old Mongol Script, also known as the Hudum Mongol bichig, is still being used and taught. Mongolia, also known as “Outer Mongolia”, adopted a Russian variant of Cyrillic, a national script language used across Eurasia, while Inner Mongolian remains the last vestige of the traditional language of Mongol heritage. If the Mongol Script is replaced by Mandarin Chinese in schools, this piece of the autonomous region’s culture becomes lost within a generation or two with Mongolian children learning Mandarin, over their ethnic language.

“If we lose the language, we have lost the most important part of our culture.”
“The Chinese government believes the changes, which will see Mandarin-language teaching from the first year of school, a separate Mongolian language course, and the replacement of Mongolian history and politics textbooks with Chinese textbooks by 2023, are necessary to ensure students in the region can compete with the best in Beijing,” says an excerpt from a piece in the Sydney Morning Herald, “They will replace the content of Genghis Khan in Mongolian language with Chairman Mao in Chinese in the new textbook.”

If this sounds far-fetched, it isn’t. In a statement by the Associated Press, an exhibition at the Château des ducs de Bretagne museum in Nantes, France, “has postponed an exhibit about Mongol Emperor Genghis Khan citing interference by the Chinese government, which it accuses of trying to rewrite history.” The director Bertrand Guillet stated “the Chinese Bureau of Cultural Heritage had demanded numerous changes, including removing the words “Genghis Khan,” “empire,” and “Mongol.”

Em solidifies the very real anxieties within Inner Mongolia and the general atmosphere of the region by explaining, “The biggest fear I’ve seen here in Inner Mongolia right now, is that the culture will disappear completely. The fear is that they will lose everything, and I don’t believe it’s an overreaction at all. We’ve seen it done already with other minorities. The difference is, we are at a point now where it can be stopped. There’s still hope.”

TOPSHOT-MONGOLIA-CHINA-DIPLOMACY-RIGHTS

Image

Mongolians protest against China’s plan to introduce Mandarin-only classes at schools in the Chinese province of Inner Mongolia, at Sukhbaatar Square in Ulaanbaatar, the capital of Mongolia on September 15, 2020 Photo by BYAMBASUREN BYAMBA-OCHIR/AFP via Getty Images

MONGOLIA VS INNER MONGOLIA
A distinction needs to be made, to better understand the context of what is happening in this region.

First, there are currently two Mongolian ethnic states. They are Inner Mongolia and Mongolia, also known as Outer Mongolia, who are distinctly different geographic “entities,” that once made up the historic Mongol empire. Over time, however, the two split due to varying circumstances.


After the fall of the Yuan Dynasty, both Mongolia and Inner Mongolia were fully incorporated into the Chinese State in the late 17th century. Then, in 1911, Mongolia (or Outer Mongolia) gained independence from the Qing dynasty before achieving nationhood in 1921, with the support of the Soviet Union. Inner Mongolia, however, remained a Mongol autonomous region under China.

Mongolia is now a completely independent country, while Inner Mongolia is an autonomous region of China, and equivalent to a province. The relationship between the People’s Republic and Inner Mongolia has historically held firm to maintaining rules and laws different from the Chinese mainland, allowing Inner Mongolia’s autonomy... until recently.

GROWING CHINESE AGGRESSION
Criticisms directed at China for violating a region’s autonomy is unfortunately nothing new.

In the 1950s under Mao Zedong, the PRC claimed sovereignty over Tibet and invaded the country. This prompted a series of events that eventually caused the Dalai Lama, an important spiritual and cultural figure for Tibet, and about 80,000 Tibetans to flee to India. Tibet, now another autonomous region of China, has faced similar cultural suppression and erasure of ethnic practices since coming under Chinese control.

After Tibet’s own mandatory Mandarin policy was enacted in 2017, Tibetan minority language schools have almost entirely been eliminated. While in 2020, it has been reported that more than 500,000 Tibetans have been transferred to Chinese training centers as part of a mass labor initiative expanded in the region, enlisting civilians through coercive means.

“The program appears disturbingly reminiscent of coercive vocational training and mass labor transfers imposed by the Chinese authorities in the Uyghur region,” read a report by anthropologist Adrian Zenz.

Zenz’s report also referenced, “accounts of enforced indoctrination, intrusive surveillance, military-style enforcement, and harsh punishments for those who fail to meet labor transfer quotas.”

Currently, China is engaging in an ongoing border dispute with India. This most recent dispute between the two Asian powers began early in 2020 and culminated in a clash last June between sides that left 20 Indian soldiers dead, along with an undisclosed number of Chinese soldiers.

In August 2020, a massive brawl reportedly involving over 500 men and lasting about three hours broke out on the disputed border between the two sides. This clash is believed to have involved the Special Frontier Force, a unit consisting mainly of Tibetan refugees. In the same month, a Tibetan soldier was killed by a landmine. Soon after, in September, “Chinese and Indian officials accused each other’s soldiers of firing warning shots, apparently the first time in decades that guns had been aggressively used along the disputed frontier.”

Not only is China engaging in aggressive actions on its border with India, but it’s also becoming increasingly antagonistic along the South China Sea towards neighbors such as Japan and the Philippines. China sunk a Vietnamese fishing vessel in April 2020 and continues naval aggression against American military vessels in the area using signaling, dangerously close maneuvering, and illuminating U.S. ships with fire-control radar, which suggests the imminent launch of weapons.

Image

Protesters use umbrellas as shields during the demonstration in Hong Kong. Photo by Stanton Sharpe/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

In 2019, protests in Hong Kong broke out as a response to an extradition bill directing back to the Chinese Mainland. Hong Kong, another autonomous zone of China, was previously under British colonial rule and returned to China in 1997. Both Hong Kong and China have maintained a “one country, two systems” arrangement since then, giving Hong Kong autonomy from the Communist Party of China, as well as from its governance. This has allowed Hong Kong to enjoy more democratic rights and freedoms than Mainland China, which included freedom of assembly, freedom of speech, and a separate legal and judiciary system.

This extradition bill that sparked mass protests, would “allow Hong Kong to detain and transfer people wanted in countries and territories with which it has no formal extradition agreements, including Taiwan and the Chinese mainland...Critics contend that the law would allow virtually anyone in the city to be picked up and detained in mainland China, a country in which judges must follow the orders of the Communist Party...The extradition plan applies to 37 crimes. That excludes political ones, but critics fear the legislation would essentially legalize the sort of abductions to the mainland that have taken place in Hong Kong in recent years.”


The autonomy, freedom, and rights granted by the “one country, two systems,” such as Hong Kong’s civil service, independent courts, free press, open internet (unlike the Great Cyber Wall) were provided by what is known as The Basic Law. The Basic Law is set to expire in 2047 and reincorporates Hong Kong with the Mainland. Still, in June 2020, Beijing enacted the Hong Kong Security Law, which was kept secret from citizens until it was passed. This essentially removed the autonomous abilities of Hong Kong, and allowed for Beijing and the Mainland “broad powers to crack down on a variety of political crimes, including separatism and collusion,” due to its ambiguous nature and has caused mass arrests after being enacted. It has aroused fears that Taiwan is next on China’s list.

And still, this is not the worst of the People’s Republic’s current political trajectory to global prominence. It gets much worse

UYGHUR GENOCIDE
Within yet another autonomous region in Northwest China, are the Uyghurs. A Turkic-speaking minority ethnic group, whose dominant religious practices is Islam. It has been reported that these ethnic minorities to the Han Chinese majority, are being rounded up and detained in unverified numbers and sent to “re-education” and work camps. Some have estimated numbers up to 7 to 10 million Uyghurs have been taken over the past few years and sent to these camps, which include forced sterilization of Uyghur women, banning of religious practices, and overt citizen surveillance.

These “re-education” and work camps have produced incidents like a seizure of a 13-ton shipment of human hair, likely from Chinese prisoners from a shipment originating in Xinjiang and other examples of detention camps and forced labor becoming part of China’s large export economy.

The plight of the Uyghurs has sparked global condemnation and recently caused the U.S. Customs and Border Protection to issue orders to freeze imports from companies that produce cotton, clothing, and computer parts in the Xinjiang region China, with companies like H&M cutting ties as well.

What the Muslim minority of Xinjiang is facing, goes behind just a cultural genocide, but meets the United Nations’ definition of genocide itself.

Image

Rally For Muslim China Uighur In Front Of China Embassy
Thousands of Muslims held a rally in front of a Chinese Embassy, to protest the treatment of Uyghurs in China. Photo by Donal Husni/NurPhoto via Getty Images


CULTURAL GENOCIDE IN INNER MONGOLIA
Regrettably, the situation unfolding in Inner Mongolia is just another instance of the People’s Republic of China wiping out minority cultures and violating human rights within their borders.

It has happened with Tibet and Xinjiang, and now Hong Kong as well. Even Taiwan, who maintains a separate government, constitution, and outright separates itself as a sovereign nation from the People’s Republic of China, faces continued and escalating border tensions from the PRC, in the Mainland’s bid to reunify the two on it’s path to reclaiming former territory.

“We’ve seen it done already with other minorities. The difference is, we are at a point now where it can be stopped. There’s still hope.”
As an autonomous region of China, Inner Mongolia is supposed to hold certain rights and privileges as provided by the agreements and laws written between the Mongolian region and the Chinese State. Honoring these have been an ongoing problem for years, culminating in the current escalation of eliminating the ethnic-cultural minority into forced assimilation.

The Mongolian minority has already lost large portions of their heritage and territory over time, pushed to the outer bounds of the region, as Han Chinese populations continue to rise and slowly remove Mongolian influence over time. This has created tensions between the two in the past, including riots in 2011 and 2013.


One prominent example of how this Han influence has impacted Mongolian culture globally is Disney’s Mulan. The real Mulan was from the Northern Wei region and of Turco-Mongolic descent, not Han Chinese.

The Northern Wei dynasty was established by a formerly nomadic group named the Tuoba, a clan of the Xianbei people, who came from northern China and likely spoke either a Turkic or proto-Mongolian language, rather than a native Chinese dialect… “The emperor is an important person in [The Ballad of Mulan], but he’s not called by his Chinese name,” says Chen. Rather than the Chinese title of Huangdi, the emperor is referred to as “Khan,” “Kehan” or “Kaghan,” depending on the translation—a title used to refer to Genghis Khan and other Mongol leaders. Chen also says that the title of the poem and the fact that it is named for the female character reflects the respected status that women held in these nomadic societies…Over time, the story and character’s nomadic and tribal origins have significantly changed from the original. Mulan has been depicted as Han Chinese in adaptations over the last century, and this process of “sinification,” or coming under the influence of Han Chinese culture.

(SP)CHINA-ORDOS-NATIONAL ETHNIC GAMES-HORSE RACING-ARCHERY(CN)

Image

Xinhua/Fei Maohua via Getty Images

Another cultural aspect that has been integral to Mongolian culture for the entirety of their recorded history is the Steppe, for which these ancient people honed their horseback riding, archery, and maintained their nomadic lifestyle. Essentially, the wide-open lands Mongols have inhabited for centuries herding livestock.

Em explains this nomadic lifestyle goes beyond just the geography, but a cultural kinship with their land.

“Mongolian culture is a culture that is a true balance between humanity and nature,” Em says. “In all of the aspects that a Mongolian lives in the traditional sense, and how many here still do, it was created with a deep philosophical understanding of how to balance this. How to live without destroying the earth. For example, look at a Ger [Mongolian yurt]. It was made to be easily moved, lightweight and the structure is specifically developed so it doesn’t destroy the grass. It has to be this way for the animals to graze and eat. The Ger walls lift up in case a flood happens and you can just let the water pass by.


“There’s also the Gutal [Mongolian wrestling boots], which have an upward pointed toe. This is done so the boot glides against the grass and doesn’t destroy it either. These are only a few beautiful examples that can show you how much Mongols view the importance of balance between human beings and our planet,” Em explains. “In the West, we have forgotten so much of this and have destroyed the earth in ways that may be irreversible. I believe the West can find balance in their own lives by understanding Mongolian culture a little deeper. Bökh is an art that can truly change and transform grappling internationally, but Mongolian culture can help change the world.”

As nomads, herding has been a way of life for thousands of years. While a lot of the changes are yet to be known for sure, there is a very real fear among Mongolians that complete loss of land and territory is on the horizon.

“Our biggest fears are two things, one is losing our land and the other is losing our language,” Aitch says. “We aren’t scared of anything, not even war, but we are very afraid of our language or our lands disappearing forever.”

Em is also corroborating earlier reports from Inner Mongolia, such as the Guardian in 2015 and petitions from 2013.

“Taking the Mongolian language from schools is only one aspect of the cultural genocide that’s happening. What’s more concerning is what’s coming next,” Em states.

“The government is taking the land and erasing Mongolian culture entirely, except to have it become a show you’ll see at new tourist attractions they plan to build. Which make no mistake about it, it is the next step and it’s already happening. Many of the Mongols here know it. Without any of this, you can’t have Mongol Bökh, you can’t have what it means to be Mongolian.”

Since the 1990s, the nomadic living of Inner Mongolians was drastically reduced and almost completely eradicated since the early 2000s according to Em, “There are only a few Inner Mongolians who can get away with living a nomadic lifestyle and they are only in certain areas. Even land that was once used for nomadic herding traditions is still being divided up. There are fences everywhere. The government only gives land to Inner Mongolians who can prove they lived there for at least 3 generations. You also don’t get to choose what you get either, good or bad land. You got what they gave you. It’s why they have ranches here now and build their Yurts next to them, rather than traditionally traveling with them.”

Of course, in a similar fashion to Hong Kong, Tibet, Xianjing, and Taiwan, China is cracking down and eliminating as much information that it can regarding what is happening in Inner Mongolia.

The LA Times detailed this in a recent report:

“The seat of government in Xilingol [Inner Mongolia], announced via WeChat that parents who did not send their children to school by Sept. 17 would lose access to government subsidies. High schoolers who did not attend classes would be expelled and blocked from taking the college entrance exam. Banks would stop loans for the next five years to any parents who did not comply…A separate government notice stated that parents who did not abide would be placed on an “untrustworthy persons list,” and face restrictions on jobs, special market transactions, cross-border travels, home reconstruction and other actions requiring good social credit standing… A police source within Inner Mongolia told the Los Angeles Times that most students had returned to school, but officers were tracking down people who had posted anything “harmful to the government” online. He shared images of police orders that included people’s names, ID and phone numbers, addresses, and workplaces, and required officers to implement “education and stability control” on the individuals. Several of the individuals were targeted for “stability control” because they’d called for protests or posted messages on WeChat about apparent Mongolian suicides. The Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center, a New York-based rights group, said that nine Mongols, mostly teachers, and students, had committed suicide in recent weeks after coming under government pressure.”

MONGOLIA-CHINA-DIPLOMACY-RIGHTS
Image

Photo by BYAMBASUREN BYAMBA-OCHIR/AFP via Getty Images

“What Mongols want Westerners to understand is that this is very real and that they need help from the outside world. It’s much worse than most people realize and it’s hard to get the real information out,” Em says about this horrifying news.

“The CCP continues to lie to the outside world, as if it’s all fake news, and pretends Mongolians are happy with propaganda videos.”
“Children were being abducted and locked into schools. Those herdsmen who kept their children from schools were threatened by the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) and even banks. The CCP told the Mongols they would take away all their rights if they refused this policy or did not allow their children to go to school. Teachers and all the government workers who fought against this policy change were either fired or arrested and many teachers and principals even committed suicide because of the pressure! Still, the CCP continues to lie to the outside world, as if it’s all fake news, and pretends Mongolians are happy with propaganda videos. The PRC has scared the Mongols and is controlling them with deep surveillance, to the point that even if they want to stand up for themselves and their culture, they would have no chance. This is all just one step to a bigger goal. Tibet, Xinjiang, Hong Kong, Inner Mongolia. They’re all the same. Next, and there will be a next, it could be you. China no longer sees a limit to who they can reach.”


The only Mongolian-language social site was shut down in China, and police have also been offering cash rewards for Inner Mongolian protesters. Reports also reveal communication blackouts as part of the government’s tactics.

“400,000 users from Inner Mongolia could not access chat groups on Bainuu. Several days later, the timelines and walls of Bainuu users were no longer available. All posts on WeChat and Weibo on Mongolian language or “bilingual education” were censored, making it difficult for people outside of Inner Mongolia to find information on protests. Over 450 WeChat users are said to have been warned by authorities. The CCP has used this kind of “communication blackout” in Xinjiang and other regions to prevent the mobilization of target groups. At least twenty-three have been detained for “flagrantly insulting a deceased former leader of the country” and for “sharing videos in a WeChat group to obstruct the implementation of the national textbooks policy.”

Bloody Elbow has reached out to the Chinese International Press Center, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China, and the Embassy of the People’s Republic of China in the USA about this issue.

As of this writing, only the Information and Public Affairs Section of the Chinese Embassy have replied to our inquiry, repeating Chinese Foreign Ministry’s spokesperson Hua Chunying’s September 3, 2020 comments, without adding anything further. In that previous statement, Hua downplayed the issue and denied any wrongdoing from the government.

“The Education Department of the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region has released relevant information on unified textbooks. In recent years, the National Textbook Committee has organized experts to compile textbooks in Chinese language and literature, politics and history, which have been used in all primary and secondary schools nationwide since 2017. Starting this year, six provinces and autonomous regions, including Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, have also started using these textbooks. The unified textbooks of the three subjects will not affect the setting of courses of other subjects in schools teaching ethnic languages. The class hours, textbooks, and teaching language of the Mongolian language and literature class will remain unchanged, and the current bilingual education system will not be changed.

The national common spoken and written language is a symbol of national sovereignty. It is every citizen’s right and duty to learn and use the national common spoken and written language. This is true not only in China, but also in the rest of the world. It is enshrined in China’s Constitution, the Law on Regional Ethnic Autonomy and the Education Law.

The Chinese government, in accordance with relevant laws, promotes the use of the national common spoken and written language in ethnic minority areas, upholds the principle of equality in the spoken and written languages of all ethnic groups, and guarantees according to law the freedom of all ethnic groups, including the Mongolian ethnicity, to use and develop their own spoken and written languages.”

Despite numerous reports, Chinese officials have also repeatedly denied any human rights abuses and wrongdoings against the Uyghurs, stating that “we treat every ethnic group as equal.”

MONGOLIA-WRESTLING-NAADAM

Image

Mongolian wrestlers compete during the traditional Nadaam festival in the Ovorkhangai province JOEL SAGET/AFP via Getty Images

MONGOLIAN BÖKH: IMPLICATIONS
What does it mean for the sport of Mongolian wrestling? At the current moment, just like with COVID-19, wrestlers are slowly integrating back into training and competition. But, unlike the pandemic that has shaped so much of 2020, returning to training is different and impacting wrestlers on a deeper level emotionally.

“If we lose our culture, our language, then Bökh simply won’t exist one day.”
“Bökh is an important part of Mongolian daily life and is involved in our life from birth to death,” Oh says. “Wherever they are, Mongolian men play and wrestle with each other. It’s how Mongols get closer to one another, there really isn’t any other way like it. It’s an expression and kinship that’s hard to express without experiencing it. It’s very much a cultural thing and there are endless elements of Mongolian culture in Bökh. The spirit of the Mongolian people is reflected in Bökh. Every gesture, movement, and smile of the Bökh’ers has influenced Mongolian culture because it’s not a sport or a game. Bökh is a psychological game. If you want to win a Bökh competition, you cannot only be strong physically but also mentally. You can imagine how our peace of mind has been affected, in something linked so much to our culture and what it does to competing.”


Oh continued, “Most of the wrestlers were in poor condition, mentally and emotionally, because they loved their language and culture, and everyone feels powerless. In ancient times, the status of a wrestler was comparable to that of the gods. Mongols regarded wrestlers as a symbol of wisdom and strength. They were guardians of their homeland in war and in peace. Now, the wrestlers feel unarmed, a bleeding of the heart. They felt very helpless. They could not solve the problem by force to protect our Mongolian language and culture.”

Image

Mongolian wrestlers at the Naadham

Em adds their thoughts to this with, “Mongols all over, especially the Mongols in the grasslands and the smaller towns, are depressed and sad. There’s a hanging feeling of hopelessness. It’s made wrestling difficult to do. People aren’t motivated to train, nor are they mentally focused. Their thoughts are elsewhere, which distracts you from having that ‘feeling’ during a match. Yet, the show must go on and a few Naadam have happened recently and it’s allowed wrestlers to get back to competing, uniting, and sharing a common goal of keeping their culture alive. Wrestling is one way to do this. Winter Training began in October and there is an even greater push to spread the art and culture internationally too.”

The culture and tradition of Bökh predate even the Greek Olympic and is a tradition that has continued for thousands of years within the region, standing the test of time and ingraining itself within Mongolia’s cultural landscape:

“Wrestling has been a part of Mongolian life for centuries. Cave paintings depict two men grappling with one another in front of a crowd. The Secret History of the Mongols, the 13th-century chronicle of Genghis Khan, praises the virtues of the sport.”

This “wrestling culture” has allowed for Mongolians to excel across the grappling arts. Mongolian wrestlers are notorious for their cross-training into different grappling disciplines and competing at the highest level, which has “led Mongolians to compete successfully in other wrestling forms, including Sumo, Judo, Shuai Jiao [Chinese Wrestling], etc. Mongolia’s long-awaited Olympic Gold Medal was earned by Tuvshinbayar Naidan, who proved his success by winning the silver medal at the 2012 Summer Olympics, in the men’s -100 category of Judo at the 2008 Summer Olympics in Beijing, China.” This success is directly related to what is taught, learned, and lived since birth in Bökh and living wrestling.


Along with archery and horseback riding, “Wrestling is the main form of entertainment in the Southern “Inner” Mongolian culture as well as the main sport that all men do at some point in their life,” says Em, who notes this sport has many women participants as well.

“Imagine if there was one thing that helped shape your entire culture for thousands of years and almost everyone does it. Remember in the grasslands, you don’t have much nor is there much to do. So, wrestling whether or not you’re doing it professionally, is just something you do to pass the time and have fun,” Em explains. “Inner Mongolians live a simple life that’s rich in human connection, connection with the earth and sky. This is something that wrestling brings us closer to.”

There is no doubt that if the PRC continues its forced assimilation of Mongolian culture, that this wrestling art will become forever changed. In turn, it can also impact the competitive landscape of Sumo, Judo, Shuai Jiao, Freestyle, and others. Bökh is simply too intertwined within what it means to be Mongolian, for the sport to not feel massive ramifications from cultural turmoil and forced influences from outside traditions.

Image

Miss World contestants enjoy a demonstration
Photo credit should read STR/AFP via Getty Images


WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD?
The ramifications of cultural genocide are well known throughout history.

If the examples of Native American’s interactions with European powers since Christopher Columbus voyage to the “New World” have taught the Western world anything, it’s that the societal and historical repercussions of cultural genocide are vast and long-lasting. The actions against the autonomous zones within China go beyond simply infringing on tradition or minor assimilation, and extends into deep human rights violations and Orwellian-like rewriting of history.

What is at stake here is not just an 800-year-old script multicultural language that harkens back to the golden era of the Silk Route. It also involves providential civil and legal rights, and more importantly, the basic human rights of an autonomous region with its own deeply rich history, cultural sovereignty, and traditional expressions.

The Mongolian Empire was one of the most impactful cultural forces in human history and helped shape our current world — more than most realize. These wrestlers are an extension of that, and they’re fighting to prevent history from repeating itself and have yet another ancient civilization become a footnote in history.

“We are struggling,” states Aitch, “We need people to understand us and to know about our culture. We need your help to protect our land and to protect our culture. We need our freedom back. We need our independence. Inner Mongolia needs independence.”

While the author is a member of the armed services, this piece is the author’s opinion and does not reflect the opinion of any military or government organization including the Department of Defense and the United States Air Force.
“Famous teachers are easy to find. It’s finding friends along the way that is hard.” -- Lü Dongbin
User avatar
Tom
Administrator
 
Posts: 4660
Joined: Tue Apr 29, 2008 8:33 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby GrahamB on Fri Nov 27, 2020 9:27 am

Thanks Tom - given that this is RSF I'm quite surprised nonbody has replied yet to inform you that there really is nothing to worry about and Inner Monogolia is all fine and dandy, you must have imaged the whole thing.
If you don't become the ocean you'll be seasick every day.
Heretics podcast | The Tai Chi Notebook
User avatar
GrahamB
Great Old One
 
Posts: 12456
Joined: Fri May 02, 2008 3:30 pm

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Tom on Fri Nov 27, 2020 11:23 am

As with the Uighurs and Tibetans, I know directly from people on the ground in Inner Mongolia that the repression and cultural erasure are indeed going on and more extensive than generally reported. This fulfills Big Daddy Xi’s goal of one big happy Han family where everyone enjoys a high social credit score.
“Famous teachers are easy to find. It’s finding friends along the way that is hard.” -- Lü Dongbin
User avatar
Tom
Administrator
 
Posts: 4660
Joined: Tue Apr 29, 2008 8:33 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Peacedog on Fri Nov 27, 2020 2:06 pm

As I've pointed out before, long term "Hanification" has always been the goal in the Chinese subcontinent.

While the Uighurs are completely screwed, as no body wants them and even the Turks have turned their back on them, the Mongolians living in the PRC can at least escape to Mongolia proper and the Tibetans have been always had both Mongolia and India as possible escape routes.

At this point, barring the short term collapse of the PRC, which I personally find unlikely, the only real choice of these ethnic groups is to run.

No one on a worldwide stage cares enough to do anything and the intentions of the Han majority within the PRC are clear.

It sucks, but this is how ethnic cleansing works and how the Han have survived as long as they have as a distinct culture. I don't see the people in charge of the PRC changing their mind and I don't see anyone getting in the way either.
Peacedog
Great Old One
 
Posts: 2076
Joined: Fri May 23, 2008 5:22 am
Location: Standing right next to your girl....

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Ian C. Kuzushi on Fri Nov 27, 2020 3:54 pm

Tom, thanks for sharing Graham's post here. As you say, it's important for its own sake in addition to contributing to the broader issue of the contemporary PRC's drive for cultural hegemony.

Peacedog wrote:As I've pointed out before, long term "Hanification" has always been the goal in the Chinese subcontinent.

While the Uighurs are completely screwed, as no body wants them and even the Turks have turned their back on them, the Mongolians living in the PRC can at least escape to Mongolia proper and the Tibetans have been always had both Mongolia and India as possible escape routes.

At this point, barring the short term collapse of the PRC, which I personally find unlikely, the only real choice of these ethnic groups is to run.

No one on a worldwide stage cares enough to do anything and the intentions of the Han majority within the PRC are clear.

It sucks, but this is how ethnic cleansing works and how the Han have survived as long as they have as a distinct culture. I don't see the people in charge of the PRC changing their mind and I don't see anyone getting in the way either.


A subcontinent can't have a goal.

The region we now think of as China has been ruled in part or entirety by non-Han peoples for half of recorded history. Not only are there dozens of diverse ethnic and cultural groups contained under the umbrella of Han identity, the notion of Han peoples has changed over time and your conception of it is in line with that of the CCP but not that of the past. In fact, you are simply pushing President Xi Jinping's artificially constructed ideological tool--I'm sure he would be grateful.

Perhaps the best way to combat this attempt as homogenization would be to point out its ahistorical nature and embrace the cultural diversity that is the reality of "China's" long and varied history. It seems that this is what some groups are already doing.
文武両道。

Lord Li requires one hundred gold coins per day!
User avatar
Ian C. Kuzushi
Great Old One
 
Posts: 2385
Joined: Sun May 15, 2011 10:02 pm

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Daniel-san on Fri Nov 27, 2020 5:15 pm

Daniel-san
Anjing
 
Posts: 112
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 12:42 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Peacedog on Fri Nov 27, 2020 6:11 pm

The reality is this is how tribes become nations and how nations maintain their position and expand over time. It is how the French became the French from a thousand little tribes, how the English became Great Britain, how the Russians became the Russians, etc.

Some societies take a slower approach of gradual conversion such as the Islamics in north Africa, others just kill the opposing side off as in the Tutsis vs the Hutus in Rwanda, other fight it out vis a vis the European settlers in North America and exile a tiny group of survivors to reservations as in the USA. At the end of the day, one cultural narrative is in charge and generally makes up the majority ethnic group although not always as in the case of Hussein era Iraq.

The ethnicity of the group in charge gradually changes as they assimilate different groups, but the cultural operating system largely remains the same. Unless that group is in turn conquered by someone else. It's why Alexander was a blondie and modern Greeks have a more Mediterranean appearance. But they're all Greeks. None of them are Spartans either.

A hundred years from now, barring something very odd happening, both the Tibetans and the Uyghurs will be historical footnotes in long forgotten books and Mongolians will survive as a separate group as long as an independent Mongolia exists. Five hundred years from now only obscure historical researchers will know anything about the first two groups and a thousand years from now they will be utterly forgotten. As has happened in countless groups of humanity over the last 80-200k years in which homo sapiens have existed.

The process of this happening is sad and lots of people die. But it is inevitable as gravity and the sun rising. It is a phenomena I have seen play out countless times over a 20 plus year career largely spent trying to keep the savages from killing each other off and exporting their idiotic problems elsewhere.

Ultimately, you can have multi-ethnic, you just can't have multicultural, because eventually people just disagree about too many things to get along with one another and they fight it out to determine who is in charge. The fact that it can take an extended period of time, as in thousands of years in some cases, based upon parity in strength between groups or a lack of resources, does not make multicultural anything work over time. It just indicates an ultimate victor has not been determined. The fall of the pagans in Western Europe and their replacement by Christianity wholesale is instructive.

The fact that the Han have not always been in the leading position during the last couple of thousand years does not change the fact that they are now as far as mainland China is concerned. They have the money, they have the weapons and they have the desire to fully subjugate and assimilate these groups. And I see nothing on the horizon that will change that.

Arguing otherwise is nothing more than yelling at a hurricane at this point. All you are going to do is lose your voice and get tired.
Last edited by Peacedog on Fri Nov 27, 2020 6:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Peacedog
Great Old One
 
Posts: 2076
Joined: Fri May 23, 2008 5:22 am
Location: Standing right next to your girl....

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Steve James on Fri Nov 27, 2020 6:47 pm

His argument in the video was about the construction of Han as a "race," and that it was adopted from European (British) racialists. So, the first thing to get out of the way is that Han is just a word, not a race and not a culture.

The argument about tribes becoming nations and then expanding is fundamentally flawed in that empires never have a single culture. They have a center of power, and a dominant group. But, a British Empire with China, India, and Egypt was definitely multicultural. There was always the fear that people stationed in the colonies would "go native."

Historically, tribes that expand also absorb. The Germans, Gauls, Franks, and Britons were Romans, but had their own cultures. In fact, the Romans tended to combine their cultures with that of those they conquered. That goes so far as to adopting a foreign religion and giving up its traditional gods. Rome is a good example because all the Romance language peoples still speak their distinctive form of Latin. (Then again, the Basques and Galicians still have their own languages and cultures.

Anyway, I found it interesting that the presenter in the video didn't mention that "white" identity (as a race) is just as made up (with sources coming from many different cultures) as Han identity. The major difference being that in the Han version or delusion they are all literally descended from the Yellow Emperor. Well, I guess it's sorta like claiming descent from Abraham. However, USAmericans are definitely NOT descended from the Father of the nation, nor does this nation belong to any tribe.
"A man is rich when he has time and freewill. How he chooses to invest both will determine the return on his investment."
User avatar
Steve James
Great Old One
 
Posts: 19655
Joined: Tue May 13, 2008 8:20 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Overlord on Fri Nov 27, 2020 7:10 pm

Thanks Tom.
-saber-


肘不離肋,手不離心
User avatar
Overlord
Wuji
 
Posts: 1677
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2008 4:03 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Franklin on Sat Nov 28, 2020 5:24 am

Ian C. Kuzushi wrote:
Peacedog wrote:As I've pointed out before, long term "Hanification" has always been the goal in the Chinese subcontinent.

...........


A subcontinent can't have a goal.

....




maybe my level of education is lacking...
I don't really have the academic credentials like others...

but saying "the goal in the chinese subcontinent"

is not anthropomorphizing the land mass itself as having goals....

or did i miss something...

or are you saying the rulers of a subcontinent can't have goals
or perhaps that china in and of itself is not a subcontinent- therefore the goals of china are not the goals of the subcontinent....


???
Last edited by Franklin on Sat Nov 28, 2020 5:25 am, edited 1 time in total.
Franklin
Great Old One
 
Posts: 1342
Joined: Tue May 13, 2008 5:56 am
Location: Taipei, Taiwan

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Bao on Sat Nov 28, 2020 7:04 am

Text to one of the pictures:

"Mongolians protest against China’s plan to introduce Mandarin-only classes at schools in the Chinese province of Inner Mongolia"

Read it correctly. It doesn't say that all classes will be in Mandarin only, but that there will be classes held in Mandarin-only. They will still have classes on their own language. China want to standardise the schools and education level across whole China. This means more classes in Mandarin only, Yes. But no one wants to take away the Mongolians their language.

In most Western countries in the World that I know about, most of the education in all schools are held in one main language. Minorities across the world have the same situation, they might speak their own language at home, but they still have to study and go to school using the main language in their country. Here the Sami use Swedish language books to study Swedish, English, Math, History and many other subjects. The Sami are not complaining, they still keep their language, their traditions and culture. So China is not allowed to do exactly the same as most countries in the West does? To keep a certain standard of education across the whole country? (Oh, sorry, yeah I know. The US doesn't. Here the standard depends on where you live and what color the people in the neighbourhood has.)

In China there are 55 minorities. Most of them have their own languages and culture. They are all bi-lingual and speak their own dialects or languages at home. They all study their own cultures and languages from small age in school or even in Kindergarten. There's no sign of any Han-isation going on anywhere in China. But as soon some kind of change happens in the system, everyone here assumes that it must be something bad because the Chinese government is bad. Whatever happens in China, people look at it through glasses of racial mistrust.

And yes, there were demonstrations in Inner Mongolia. Good for them. Do you really believe that if there was a genocide going on in the close neighbourhood that people would even dare to speak up?
Last edited by Bao on Sat Nov 28, 2020 7:13 am, edited 2 times in total.
Thoughts on Tai Chi (My Tai Chi blog)
- Storms make oaks take deeper root. -George Herbert
- To affect the quality of the day, is the highest of all arts! -Walden Thoreau
Bao
Great Old One
 
Posts: 7731
Joined: Tue May 13, 2008 12:46 pm
Location: High up north

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby GrahamB on Sat Nov 28, 2020 7:19 am

Bao wrote:Text to one of the pictures:

"Mongolians protest against China’s plan to introduce Mandarin-only classes at schools in the Chinese province of Inner Mongolia"

Read it correctly. It doesn't say that all classes will be in Mandarin only, but that there will be classes held in Mandarin-only. They will still have classes on their own language. China want to standardise the schools and education level across whole China. This means more classes in Mandarin only, Yes. But no one wants to take away the Mongolians their language.
...
And yes, there were demonstrations in Inner Mongolia. Good for them. Do you really believe that if there was a genocide going on in the close neighbourhood that people would even dare to speak up?


For somebody who places so much stock in the extact grammar of the first part of this (which I think you're reading wrongly).... to then not understand the difference between "genocide" and "cultural genocide" is, quite frankly, stunning.
If you don't become the ocean you'll be seasick every day.
Heretics podcast | The Tai Chi Notebook
User avatar
GrahamB
Great Old One
 
Posts: 12456
Joined: Fri May 02, 2008 3:30 pm

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Ian C. Kuzushi on Sat Nov 28, 2020 7:50 am

Franklin wrote:
Ian C. Kuzushi wrote:
Peacedog wrote:As I've pointed out before, long term "Hanification" has always been the goal in the Chinese subcontinent.

...........


A subcontinent can't have a goal.

....




maybe my level of education is lacking...
I don't really have the academic credentials like others...

but saying "the goal in the chinese subcontinent"

is not anthropomorphizing the land mass itself as having goals....

or did i miss something...

or are you saying the rulers of a subcontinent can't have goals
or perhaps that china in and of itself is not a subcontinent- therefore the goals of china are not the goals of the subcontinent....


???


Of course the statement is anthropomorphizing a landmass. And, that sort of slip is important to point out precisely because it gets to the erroneous underpinnings of Peacedog's analysis which always come down to race, nation, and a hodgepodge of talking points from right-wing podcasts. It erases the diversity of agency and contingency that are part and parcel of historic understanding. Instead, everything boils down to some version of the white man's burden.

How old do you think the PRC is? Or China? Or conceptions of the Han people as understood today?
文武両道。

Lord Li requires one hundred gold coins per day!
User avatar
Ian C. Kuzushi
Great Old One
 
Posts: 2385
Joined: Sun May 15, 2011 10:02 pm

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Steve James on Sat Nov 28, 2020 8:00 am

So China is not allowed to do exactly the same as most countries in the West does? To keep a certain standard of education across the whole country? (Oh, sorry, yeah I know. The US doesn't. Here the standard depends on where you live and what color the people in the neighbourhood has.)


That's a good point. The US has had a history of cultural extermination --up to making it illegal for Native peoples to speak their own languages --or simply wear eagle feathers or traditional ornaments at school graduations. Way back, they called it "civilizing" the savages. It continued well into the 20th century.

However, "English only" didn't even work in British Canada. In fact, in the Britain Isles, there has been a resurgence of cultural heritage and languages (Welsh, Gaelic, etc), and the Scots have their own thing. What English has (somewhat) is a standard written language.
So, I understand the point about the need in China for a common written language. However, isn't that the case already?

I actually agree with having a national educational curriculum. I even agree that people need to learn the standard language in order to be employable. It's no different here in the states. Well, except there are so many people who are actively against academic education yet demand English-only. I believe that instituting culture as a policy can be ruthless --and more akin to the goals of South African apartheid.

Anyway, here's the important aspect from my perspective.
n China there are 55 minorities. Most of them have their own languages and culture. They are all bi-lingual and speak their own dialects or languages at home....
Do you really believe that if there was a genocide going on in the close neighbourhood that people would even dare to speak up?


The problem is that you're speaking for them. And, the fact that some are complaining doesn't mean that it's not happening. I didn't read that they were claiming genocide. I thought it was about attempts to erase their cultures.
"A man is rich when he has time and freewill. How he chooses to invest both will determine the return on his investment."
User avatar
Steve James
Great Old One
 
Posts: 19655
Joined: Tue May 13, 2008 8:20 am

Re: Bokh wrestling and the cultural genocide in Inner Mongolia

Postby Franklin on Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:09 am

Ian C. Kuzushi wrote:
Of course the statement is anthropomorphizing a landmass. And, that sort of slip is important to point out precisely because it gets to the erroneous underpinnings of Peacedog's analysis which always come down to race, nation, and a hodgepodge of talking points from right-wing podcasts. It erases the diversity of agency and contingency that are part and parcel of historic understanding. Instead, everything boils down to some version of the white man's burden.

How old do you think the PRC is? Or China? Or conceptions of the Han people as understood today?



re-
"Of course the statement is anthropomorphizing a landmass."

huh ??? i really don't understand this...

i thought he was referencing - people in the region having those goal...

as in
if the people who control that region (or a majority of that region) have certain goals in which they are carrying out
then wouldn't we say
the goals in that region seem to be...

i really don't understand the nuance that you are trying to convey
Franklin
Great Old One
 
Posts: 1342
Joined: Tue May 13, 2008 5:56 am
Location: Taipei, Taiwan

Next

Return to Off the Topic

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests