roger bu hao wrote:
Fubo -
Thanks that's the kind of info I was wondering about. Sorry about the guilding the lilly
thing but I was trying to say in a nice way that they weren't really disciples at all and that you said that
to beef things up. Hey - that's OK and I am most def not saying that their skills are lacking or that their
teaching under Gen Sun was lacking. I am saying that I don't think Gen Sun was a disciple and that he didn't
ever name any disciples. I could be wrong. I just don't think that there was ever disciple one in the entire
Fu system. I am intensely interested in all things Fu style so I am intensely interested in Gen sun lineage.
There is no debate on the Fu lineage because it is modern history. It is the same as hearing about a tree of
my family that I never knew existed so I want to know more.
Roger,
I didn't say disciple to beef anything up and I don't feel the need to do so - they were disciples of Sun which is why I said that - I don't have any reason to doubt them - seems like you jumped to conclusions about me (and Sun's disciple situation), but it might help to ask first next time. I think the whole disciple/master thing is silly and out dated so it's not really something I would try to beef anything up with.
As for a tree of some of Fu's disciples and their's... http://www.wudangboxing.com/lineage.htm FYI.