MaartenSFS wrote:I just watched the entire third video. I can't believe how long that went on for. I still stand by my original assessment. He may be able to really Fajin, but in this video his students are obviously helping him..
MaartenSFS wrote:As to the second video, it's not the best I've seen, but better than most. I would not say that there is no Neijin. Clearly not as good as the last one, though.
MaartenSFS wrote:The bounce or shake is a result of the Fajin, not the goal.
robert wrote:MaartenSFS wrote:I just watched the entire third video. I can't believe how long that went on for. I still stand by my original assessment. He may be able to really Fajin, but in this video his students are obviously helping him..
OK, I didn't know what you meant. Originally I just watched the first 20 or 30 seconds, it gets worse in the middle. Watching from the beginning the second guy, the biggest guy looks like a reasonable uke (training partner). He lets the teacher demonstrate on him, but doesn't add to it. I agree that the third guy is obviously helping or adding to what the teacher is doing.MaartenSFS wrote:As to the second video, it's not the best I've seen, but better than most. I would not say that there is no Neijin. Clearly not as good as the last one, though.
I provided rationale as to why I don't think he's using neijin. If I've overlooked something I'd like to know what it is. I'm learning taiji, I'm very much a student; if you can point out what I'm missing I would appreciate it.
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests