everything wrote:It depends on what you want to do. If you want to be like Fedor or Adesanya or whatever, you should do what they did.
If you want that venn diagram intersection of neigong and MA for whatever reason, you should do that. "Neijia" was apparently a label Sun came up with, and he seems to give extremely, extremely clear definitions and descriptions. So why not use those? No idea why people think it would be anything else. If they think it's "fascia" or some such nonsense, they should just say they do "fascia MA" or "eccentric MA" or whatever. NO IDEA why they would think they are on Sun's level, either, that they could "found" or interpret any of that correctly. That seems incomprehensibly arrogant. It would be like me trying to say Einstein was wrong when I no (about) so little physics. /rant
Kelley Graham wrote:it's obvious that the lack of a serious definition is an issue.
everything wrote: "Neijia" was apparently a label Sun came up with, and
he seems to give extremely, extremely clear definitions and descriptions. So why not use those? No idea why people think it would be anything else.
everything wrote:"Neijia" was apparently a label Sun came up with, and he seems to give extremely, extremely clear definitions and descriptions. So why not use those? No idea why people think it would be anything else. If they think it's "fascia" or some such nonsense, they should just say they do "fascia MA" or "eccentric MA" or whatever. NO IDEA why they would think they are on Sun's level, either, that they could "found" or interpret any of that correctly. That seems incomprehensibly arrogant. It would be like me trying to say Einstein was wrong when I know (about) so little physics. /rant
wiesiek wrote:so,
we have to go over those two, to reach the one,
`caue there is no difference when you get there.
You can go from external to internal, or in reverse order, doesn`t matter. It is personal choice, but you have to get both under your belt if you hope to find the one.
What is most important during the way thru?
Harmony and inner peace
then, I can think of "3rd way" , when both are cultivated/practised equally from the start.
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests